Impact of signal retimings on traffic speeds on Valencia Street

I think 14th and 15th Streets must be part of a different synchronized system that keeps them from being part of this. Speeds are in miles per hour and are overall through speeds including stops.

 

Data from Cabspotting.

 

Streetsblog articles about the retiming: January, 2011, March, 2009, January, 2009

Fabien Girardin faved this
  • Terence Chang 4y

    Interesting, I hadn't heard about this. Now I'm curious to see if the data backs their claims. Can you tell in 2008 how low speeds got due to congestion during peak traffic? And when congestion was low did speeds get close to 25? Any sense of vehicle throughput?
  • Eric Fischer 4y

    I don't think I can make any claims about total throughput since all I have is the samples from whatever taxis happened to be on the street at any given time. I don't know if I have enough data to differentiate speeds at different times of day, but I'll give it a try tonight and see what it looks like.
  • Eric Fischer 4y

    OK, I plotted it hour by hour, with a lot of noise but not totally garbage:
    Average traffic speeds on Valencia Street at different times of day (2008) by Eric Fischer


    I don't see any evidence that speed was ever that far below the current average speed, even at the hours of highest congestion. Speeds do appear to have been somewhat higher at some times of day.
  • Marty E 4y

    i should have viewed this slide first! this is very interesting - I hope it provides some comfort that signal time makes for safer driving and for pedestrians and bicyclists as well
  • Eric Fischer 4y

    I think it is a great street for walking and a good one for biking, and I hope it keeps on getting better. I have to wonder if most drivers even notice that the overall speed is lower than it used to be. I doubt that they do.
  • calgrad1995 4y

    How many cabs did you have for each hour?
  • Eric Fischer 4y

    Number of samples for each hour of the day:

    2008: 7117 6041 4128 1900 1155 944 1398 1765 1614 1872 1777 1952 1854 2049 2120 2225 2752 3006 4281 5271 5717 5295 5773 6950
    2010: 26975 27861 17208 7321 4720 4368 6029 9253 9297 9031 9595 9577 9755 9559 9788 9602 11754 14220 18918 25531 26473 24906 26053 30536
  • andrew 4y

    Time to drive on Guerrero.
1,601 views
1 fave
8 comments
Uploaded on January 13, 2011
This photo is in 1 album

Additional info

  • Viewing this photo Public
  • Safety level of this photo Safe
  • S Search
    Photo navigation
    < > Thumbnail navigation
    Z Zoom
    B Back to context