Tamron vs Sigma vs Canon

there shall be only 1 standing in the end

 

Tamron 17-50 f2.8 vs Sigma 24-70 f2.8 (non HSM) vs Canon 24-105 IS F4 L

 

The Tamron 17-50 f2.8

Sharpness: Sharp (4/5)

AF Speed: slow (3/5)

Low light AF: Fast (5/5)

Usable range for event: (4/5)

Ideal lens to be partner: Tokina 11-16mm f2.8 and 70-200mm f2.8

 

Sigma 24-70 f2.8 DG Macro

Sharpness: Moderate Sharp (3/5) can be very soft at certain range

AF Speed: Moderate (4/5)

Low light AF: Hunt + Slow (3/5)

Usable range for event: (3/5)

Ideal lens to be partner: Tokina 12-24mm f4 and 70-200mm f2.8

 

Canon 24-105 IS F4 L

Sharpness: Sharp (5/5)

AF Speed: Fast (5/5)

Low light AF: Sometimes hunting (4/5)

Usable range for event: (4/5)

Ideal lens to be partner: Tokina 12-24mm f4

sample of sharpness @100% crop

 

Stobe info:

Nikon Sb80DX on cam right at 1/32 @ 24mm

Canon 580 EX II on cam eTTL.

 

Surprisingly, this make it to Explore. Thank you.

  • Made Wirawan 6y

    wow.. useful review
  • -go crazy 6y

    hey, i want to buy the 24-105mm but i dont know if the 4F is enough for low light.. i suppose the L lens elements are brighter though.
    & is IS a good alternative to the 2.8F ?
  • Vincent Pang 6y

    -go crazy good enough if u have 5D MK II :) boost up the ISO... NO IS is not an alternative nor replacement for f2.8... it's just handy to have IS when you are shooting at the tele end 105mm @ 1/30s :)

    f2.8 will give you a faster shutter but at the cost of thinner DOF. Because of that, i still shoot at f3.5 - f4 to be on the safe side.
  • -go crazy 6y

    Oh DoF is not an issue for me, i actually love a good blur effect for portraits! i consider buying a canon 40D. i think the 24-70 is better for my needs. thank you!
  • Alberto Feltrin 6y

    IMHO

    The Tamron 17-50 f2.8
    Sharpness: Sharp (5/5)
    AF Speed: slow (4/5)
    Low light AF: (5/5)

    and it's a bargain lens! :)
  • Vincent Pang 6y

    Alberto Feltrin yup agreed that it's a bargain lens :) no doubt about it :)
  • Tim Newman 6y

    I love my Tamron 17-50mm on my xti!! But I'm selling it ONLY because I'm moving up to a 5d mark II. I feel I need that range though, I can't afford to buy the camera and a canon 24-70 f/2.8 (which I would choose over the 24-105 mainly for the 2.8 aperture) I am going with the sigma 24-70mm 2.8.

    What do you think about the tamron 28-75 f/2.8?
  • Alberto Feltrin 6y

    to Tim Newman

    do you mean the new sigma "HSM" or the old one "macro"!?! because the new "HSM" version costs as much as the canon one!
  • Vincent Pang 6y

    Tim Newman i found the tamron 28-75mm f2.8 to be slightly sharper and more accurate in AF than the sigma. I was told it is the same as the 17-50mm f2.8 except it's 28-75mm
  • Photographer in Batumi - www.samsarkisyan.com 6y

    Canon 100-400 by Photographer in Batumi - www.samsarkisyan.com
  • Vincent Pang 5y

    Phil the tammy is a great lens if u ask me
  • Alberto Feltrin 5y

    yes, i use it @f9 in party shots and it is amazingly sharp! and it's really cheap!!!
  • Tim Newman 5y

    I was actually able to afford getting the 24-70L back in September. Love it and works great on full frame!
  • Jessada Juntason 5y

    I bought SD780IS about a month ago and I couldn't have been happier. I've taken about 500 photos so far and 50 video clips and they're all perfect!
  • lonnie 5y

    Hi, I'm an admin for a group called MY FLICKR FAV's (Invite a Friends Photo), and we'd love to have this added to the group!
  • lenovo_T500 5y

    Hey do you have any other comments about the Tamron 17-50 f2.8? Thanks!
  • Alberto Feltrin 5y

    lenovo_T500 it's a great lens :)
  • Joe Papagoda 5y

    What are the sigma lenses made from? The material looks so different than others.
  • Alberto Feltrin 5y

    it's a different finish, however, they are changing it in the new ones.. look farm5.static.flickr.com/4122/4911619303_9a1c561a73_b.jpg
  • Vincent Pang 5y

    Joe Papagoda not sure wat's the material, look like some sort of matte coating which has tendency to peel after some use. It's great that they are changing the finishing as pointed by Alberto Feltrin.
103,237 views
46 faves
29 comments
Taken on January 12, 2009
This photo is in 2 albums
This photo is in 1 gallery

Additional info

  • Viewing this photo Public
  • Safety level of this photo Safe
  • S Search
    Photo navigation
    < > Thumbnail navigation
    Z Zoom
    B Back to context