new icn messageflickr-free-ic3d pan white
Book Personification in Japan and America | by timtak
Back to photostream

Book Personification in Japan and America

Marius Brill, an author who was in my class at primary school wrote "Making Love: A Conspiracy Of The Heart" about a book that is alive and speaks. I read it and thought that, at the very least, the idea of a living book about love was excellent.

 

Bearing in mind that Westerners tend to have a "narrative self" (Bruner, Hermans and Kempen, Gottshcall, Denett and many others) believe themselves to be "the hero of their own self narrative" (Nisbett, in conversation) and come from a religious tradition in which "the Word was made flesh and dwelt amongst us", and that our lives are recorded in the book of Saint Peter, the personification of books is not without precedent. In Japan however, I argue the self is that which is portrayed by a mental manga, movie, or animation, centring upon the face or mask (Watsuji), the main God is a mirror made heart, and the Japanese version of St. Peter (Lord Enma) keeps only the names of the dead in his book; their lives recorded on a DVD-like mirror, and masks and statues are more often personified or animated.

 

To test the hypothesis that Westerners would be more likely likely to personify books than Japanese I googled "top 100 English novels" choosing the top of the list and counted the number of books with then name of an individual (such as the first two on the list Ulysses and "The Great Gatsby) and people (such as "Sons and Lovers") and similar such titles in a list of 100 Japanese novels to find that yes, there are more personified Books in the Western tradition. There are quite a lot of personified novels in Japan too such as Bocchan, and the Dancer from Izu(Chi Squared p <.4). If I had used the second of the two rankings "Provided by the Readers" on the same American site which has 28 personified novels then the difference would have approached significance (p=0.1).

  

The Guardian list of 100 best novels written in English has 31 named after people, generic or specific. They are:

Robinson Crusoe

Clarissa

Tom Jones

Emma

Sybil

Jane Eyre

David Copperfield

Little Women

Jude the Obscure

Dracula

Sister Carrie

Kim

Hadrian the Seventh

Zuleika Dobson

The Good Soldier

Ulysses

Babbitt

Mrs Dalloway

The Great Gatsby

Lolly Willowes

Murphy

All the King’s Men

The Catcher in the Rye

Lord of the Flies

Lolita

A Single Man

Mrs Palfrey at the Claremont

Midnight’s Children

An Artist of the Floating World

Babbitt

Voss

 

498 views
0 faves
0 comments
Uploaded on November 2, 2016