new icn messageflickr-free-ic3d pan white

cookies

I've included links to the recipes. You may notice that there are six recipes and wonder if there are actually six different types of cookies on that plate. I unpacked one of the cookie packages for this photo and it only had five different cookies in it. I didn't want to rummage through the other packages to find the missing cookie.

 

Which recipe isn't represented? I don't know. After I mixed all the doughs, I lost track of which was which. I was a little over-cookied to taste them all and sort it out.

 

I ran into my first problem early on. The New York Times cookie recipe instructions were to mix the butter with a paddle attachment until "very light." Instead, I mixed the butter with a spoon until I got a blister.

 

The second problem was the temperature control on the oven. It wasn't until after I checked the first batch of cookies that I threw a thermometer in there: 200 degrees, not 350 as the recipe called for and the oven setting indicated. I decided that there was no way that I could really be faithful to the recipes at this point and I completely abandoned them. I shaped the cookies in balls and crescents instead of pressing them. I made the cookies larger than the recipes called for. I baked them until they looked ready.

 

Were they any good? I've still only had nibbles of most of them. It'll be a while before I'll get excited about eating another cookie. These were a little dry and all of the flavors I added weren't necessarily very prominent. But I used good sugar and good butter and lots of it. I think with a little milk they're perfectably acceptable cookies.

 

www.nytimes.com/2008/07/09/dining/091crex.html

www.gourmet.com/recipes/2000s/2006/12/pistachio-cranberry...

www.gourmet.com/recipes/1950s/1958/10/brazil-nut-crescents

www.gourmet.com/recipes/1960s/1961/06/brown-butter-cookies

www.gourmet.com/recipes/1960s/1962/07/cottage-cheese-cookies

www.gourmet.com/recipes/1980s/1983/03/norwegian-butter-co...

5,523 views
0 faves
0 comments
Taken on December 13, 2008