Help / The Help Forum

Hot Topics

[Official Thread] Have an idea for Flickr? Share it here.
Latest: 21 hours ago
[Updated April 15] Beginning Rollout of New Flickr Notifications Center and Settings
Latest: 6 days ago
[Updated April 26, 2021] Flickr is moving payments to Stripe
Latest: 8 months ago
Welcome to the Flickr Help Forum! Click here to get started and to read our Forum Guidelines.
Latest: 14 months ago

 

Current Discussion

Deleting words from the stored tags after uploading a new image.
Latest: 60 minutes ago
Lightroom 6.14 export errors with jfFlickr plugin
Latest: 81 minutes ago
[Identified] Error when I try to add tags in Batch editing
Latest: 2 hours ago
remove account
Latest: 16 hours ago
Adding tags to multiple pictures
Latest: 16 hours ago
How to restrict website viewing to only the shared photo
Latest: 16 hours ago
Can't save Group icon
Latest: 22 hours ago
maplogs.com :(
Latest: 22 hours ago
photo totals in a few albums listed wrong
Latest: 27 hours ago
[Acknowledged by Flickr Staff] My total views
Latest: 2 days ago
unresolved issue with searching for tagged images
Latest: 2 days ago
MacOS Monterey Safari won't log in
Latest: 2 days ago
More...

Search the Help Forum

Black video thumbnails once again

szabolcs.mosonyi says:

Dear All,

I've read through earlier threads and I'm aware that flickr takes the first frame to make a thumbnail. However, I'm starting to think flickr randomly adds a black first frame to uploaded videos:
- All my videos are made using my phone. I simply start recording, then I stop. I don't add effects, no fade-in, no video editing, nothing. Yet some of my videos have uploaded correctly with a thumbnail, many have not. When I play back my video on flickr, the first frame does appear to be black. Then I download the video back to my computer and I open it with VLC player, I set frame by frame playback and I don't see any black frame.

Please someone tell me how to avoid a black thumbnail or how to remove a first frame easily. It's really frustrating. It's already enough inconvenience that flickr cannot take the correct date of recording but I'm now used to changing that manually. The black screen is simply too much, I don't want to start manually editing every video. Is there really no way to fix this? Thanks for any constructive suggestion.
Posted at 5:31AM, 17 July 2021 PDT ( permalink | reply )

view photos

John Frattura says:

szabolcs.mosonyi:

Can you provide a link to a video in your photostream that has this problem?
Posted 3 weeks ago. ( permalink | reply )

view photos

szabolcs.mosonyi says:

John Frattura:

Hi John,

Most of them are hidden as they are about my daughter, but I've made one public temporarily:
www.flickr.com/photos/szabolcs-mosonyi/51316344632/in/dat...

Thanks for looking into it.
Posted 3 weeks ago. ( permalink | reply )

view photos

Flickr Staff

R L Catlow says:

szabolcs.mosonyi:

Hi there,

The reason some of your videos are black has to do with the first frame of the video that you are uploading.

This is likely because your video fades in from black.

Flickr by default uses the first frame as the thumbnail for any video that is uploaded, currently there is not a way to change this within the website.

You would need to edit out the first frame for these videos in order to see anything but a black frame.

Thanks!
Posted 2 weeks ago. ( permalink | reply )

view photos

janeallison says:

Not so. I opened a sample video in iMovie to see if there is a black frame at the beginning. There is not. How would there be a black frame if I merely press the button on my smart phone to start recording.

There is no black first frame on my videos and they show up black.

Try this one flic.kr/p/2mcvmox

The black thumbnails on my album look hideous. How can I fix it.

This issue has been brought up repeatedly in the forum over several years. Flickr always gives the answer you did about the black frame and it’s baloney. Please look into it and fix it.
Posted 2 weeks ago. ( permalink | reply )

view photos

Flickr Staff

katie_ko says:

janeallison:

Thanks for the feedback! We understand that a number of people experience this issue & while Ryan’s explanation is above is accurate-- I’d like to offer some additional context that might be useful here.

We’re aware of a bug from Samsung devices that creates a millisecond black frame in videos.

Different video players handle files differently, so while some players skip over the first frame, other players (including Flickr’s) see and preserve the entire video, including that leading black frame.

We’ve previously made Samsung aware of this, but feel free to report the issue to Samsung Support directly in attempts to have it prioritized.

In the meantime, you can try cropping out the first frame in these videos in order to avoid seeing that leading black frame as a thumbnail.
Posted 2 weeks ago. ( permalink | reply )

view photos

szabolcs.mosonyi says:

katie_ko:

Hi, thanks for the feedback, yours is much more useful than the first staff comment was as I was already aware of the first frame rule but I'm sure my videos do not fade in, I simply start recording. However, do you have any suggestions on how to crop out the first frame? I guess many users, including myself, do not edit videos and do not use any software. I'm looking for the simplest/quickest solution possible. Thanks in advance.
Posted 2 weeks ago. ( permalink | reply )

Subscribe to a feed of stuff on this page... Feed – Subscribe to help discussion threads