You aren't signed in     Sign In    Help

Side by Side of Asian women and Caucasian Women

Side by Side of Asian women and Caucasian Women by Tricia Wang 王圣捷.
I performed a Google Image Search just on "Asian women," "American women," and "Asian American women" for a presentation that I made on stereotypes and identities of Asian American Youth. I wanted to demonstrate the pervasive stereotypes of Asian women as hyper-hyper sexualized bodies and that general cultural stereotype was also evident in a simple online image search where the rankings are based on algorithms.

The screenshot of the results are in the picture above. You can see a comparison of the results for Asian Women (on the left) in comparison to Caucasian Women (on the right). The Asian American Google Image Search revealed pictures of every Asian woman naked, legs spread open, and in a sexual positions. In contrast, the Caucasian Women search revealed a variety of images of women from wearing suits to profile shots. None of the Caucasian women were naked or in a sexual position.

When I presented my search during my talk, someone asked ted me to type in “Korean, Japanese, black, African America." Even after performing each of those searchers, “Asian women” still won as the most sexualized google image search. When you perform the search based on more specific cultures, like “Dominican” - it’s not as sexualized as “Latina.” Same for when you search “Japanese” - it’s not as sexualized as “Asian.” Sometimes sweeping stereotypes are easier for mass groupings of people.

From the search results, there are no other groups that are as sexualized as the generic “Asian woman.” Latina comes the closest. You can see for “Arab women” you can plenty of images of the stereotypes veiled woman.

SO for Google searches – it’s just based on algorithms on what users are clicking through and page ranking based on how many sites point to the webpage - which all determines the relevancy of the answers to the search query.
But just a simple Google search can show the type of social stereotypes that exist out there – based on the distribution of what internet users are clicking, pointing and linking to. And in this case I think it can even demonstrate the extent of a stereotype. In Google image search, there are no hierarchies of approval that the images have to go through as opposed to traditional media (newspapers, TV shows and etc), where images usually become racialized in the approval process. Try the google search yourself -make sure the "safe mode" it turned off.

click on the set to see the other see the other google searches I performed or try your own google image search - make sure the "safe mode" it turned off. 

Comments

view profile

digitalexistence  Pro User  says:

This is a fascinating thesis, Tricia, but there are some caveats. Try doing searches on "white girls" and "black girls" and you'll find a similar degree of sexual imagery as "asian women" (or "asian girls" for that matter). Is it that Asian women are hyper-sexualized, or is it that any search with a correlation between females and race has clear sexual overtones?

Also, if exoticism is the root cause behind this skewed distribution, it's unlikely that search results would represent women that match the majority beauty norm to the same degree as for other "races". In other words, it would be interesting and necessary to follow up these conjectures with evidence from Asian and other countries on the prevalence of non-native women in search results (research which is unfortunately hampered by governmental influence in most countries--liberalized Japan may be a good place to attempt this).

Also note that the definition of "Asian" differs between British and American usage of the word--Americans use it exclusively to refer to people from the Far East, whereas Brits include people from South Asia (India and neighbors). Looking through the search results, it's clear that the American usage is predominant. My guess, though I don't have evidence to prove it, is that American websites dominate most search results for U.S.-based Google and others, so there could be some form of selection bias at play here also (i.e. American laws don't prohibit most forms of online sexual content).

In any case, keep the good ideas coming!
Posted 37 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

digitalexistence  Pro User  says:

Another interesting experiment--try substituting the following words instead of "women" and see what you get:

- girl(s)
- lady/ies
- female(s)
- bitch(es)
- babe(s)
- chick(s)

Clearly, some of these have more sexual connotation than others, and are used in different ways colloquially. For example, "ladies" seems to be used more often when describing dating opportunities versus sexual encounters.

Also note that many hits lead back to the same sites (particularly for Arab or Indian search results), indicating that perhaps only a handful of sites are being particularly successful in generating broad search coverage--search results are not only indicative of what people are actually searching for, but also of what people are posting online, and pornographic sites are well-known for traffic manipulation.
Posted 37 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

foxdougan says:

This is very interesting - using Google Image Search to check for stereotyping by race.

It's kind of opened my eyes as to how shunned some asian women are in society. This is probably due to caucasian men believing that their own race is nice and normal, whilst others are 'alternative' and sure to their differences are likely to be sexually deviant too.

I agree with digitalexistance but the image is still thought-provoking.

-Foxy
Posted 37 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

digitalexistence  Pro User  says:

Note that in China and some other Asian countries, Western women are stereotyped as morally loose and similarly fetishized, though perhaps not as overtly. While this reputation is probably accurate to a degree given comparatively liberal Western cultures, it is no more accurate, or inaccurate, than other stereotypes when used to describe individuals. I dont say this tto explain away the effect stereotypes may have in American culture, as Tricia is trying to illuminate, but once you start getting comparative, some interesting patterns begin to appear; it makes me wonder what the root causes are, and if they have sociobiological or cultural origins, or some degree of both. It's my opinion that before we can really work to dispel stereotypes, we must understand their societal purpose and origin; it's not enough to acknowledge their existence, and in fact can we even be sure they exist in the form we assume wihout this information?
Posted 37 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Tricia Wang 王圣捷  Pro User  says:

hey todd - interesting on idea on subsituting women with "chic and etc."
I only used women b.c woman by itself is not a sexually charged, seemingly degrading, sexist or contested word in itself (not that I am saying calling a woman a "chic" is degrading, but it can be depending on the usage). "woman" and "man" semantically speaking are are not colloquial words. So if you do searches with colloquial words that have contested, multiple or ambiguously charged meanings then it would be of no surprise if the search results reflected that. If you search for girls - you're probably going to get lots of prepubescent sexualized images. And your example of "Ladies" shows just that - that the word "lady" connotes and signifies something very different from "woman." But I think we can all agree other than "female," women is the term we use to describe the US dichotomous gender system - woman and man.
and YES great point on how the US/Western nation dominates the cyberscape - even in google searches - it's a great example to show the varous levels of hierarchy.

well if anyone is trying this search from a different country - let us know if you get different results.
Posted 37 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Tempboogie  Pro User  says:

love it
Posted 36 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

es ley  Pro User  says:

very interesting!
Posted 27 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

cgrettramkk says:

cool photos.
almost as asian babe photos
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

[?]

Tricia Wang 王圣捷's photostream

17,148
uploads

This photo also belongs to:

Google Search Algorithms as Revealing of Collective Social Stereotypes: The Hyper-Sexualized Asian American Woman (Set)

12
items

Puerto Nuevo-Baja Mexico (Set)

43
items

Tags

Additional Information

AttributionNoncommercialShare Alike Some rights reserved Anyone can see this photo

Add to your map