You aren't signed in     Sign In    Help

Racing Stars

its like a contrast between two mediums
Racing Stars by Andrew Stawarz.
Take two at filling this in with the whole commentary as for some reason the original disappeared Wednesday night/Thursday morning.

I have been itching to do a star trail picture for a long while and on Monday night decided to head out to Rougham Control Tower (Google Map) on a cold frosty night with aching stomach.

The set up to do this picture was as follows:

1. Camera firmly mounted on a weighted tripod. With a hot shoe spirit level ensured the camera was horizontally level. With a compass and locating the great bear ensured that camera was pointing due north towards the pole star (to obtain the circle of stars).

2. The camera, a Nikon D300, was set to manual mode, 30 second exposure, aperture wide open on the Sigma 10-20 at f/4, focal length of 10mm, manually focused to infinity and the ISO adjusted with a number of test shots until the stars would appreciably show, in this case ISO 800 (owing to the background light off nearby Bury St Edmunds and Moreton Hall). Continuous shooting mode was enabled with 100 exposures maximum batch limit. The white balance was set to Daylight.

3. Using a wired remote release the shutter was triggered and the remote release locked down. The camera will now continuously take 30 second exposures (long enough to register the stars but short enough not the significantly register the foreground and back lighting) automatically for 100 exposures.

4. Then I sat on my Karrimat with hot coffee and listened to the latest from Scott and the crew on TWiP on the iPod whilst I watched the frost build up on the grass and the stars whiz over.

5. 10 minutes in and a Muntjac deer came barrelling through a hedge and across the grass till it bounced off the tripod and me. So after some cursing, realignment and brushing myself down, I started again.

6. After the 100 initial exposures, the camera was set to f8 and focus to hyperfocal distance so that I can take one image where I light painted the control tower with a 3W LED torch (using day light white balance appeared accurate whilst giving a gentle glow to the background light in the distance).

7. Finally 1 last image was taken with the lens cap on as a dark frame for later noise assessment during post processing.

8. So after 102 images, feeling very cold and the imodium wearing off, I headed back home after completing the tedious part.

Now for the post-processing.

1. This could have been done by loading the stack of images into Photoshop and use "lighten" blending but the memory requirement would have been horrific with full size 12.3MP camera images.

2. Instead I used an application called Startrails to do the blending. The 100 normal images plus the light painted one was selected for the blending and the single dark frame one. As noise wasn't too bad for the camera a single dark frame was ok. Otherwise 3 dark frame could be used taken every 33 images just in case there is any variance. The images where blended and the result saved as a TIFF. The application can do a video of the star movement but didn't seemed to work on any of my Vista PCs.

3. The TIFF file was then imported and converted to DNG into Adobe Lightroom where a little curve work was applied to improve contrast, some luminance and saturation of colours and final output sharpening on export for the image posted here.

So the lessons learnt from this exercise were:

1. Bring a hat and gloves, it was freezing at ground level.

2. Find a location with less background light.

3. Bring more hot coffee.

All an in a very pleasing first attempt at doing star trails and surely try this again using other buildings.

Update: Looked again at using Photoshop CS3 Extended to do the merge of all 101 pictures (not including the dark frame). Easiest method is to use the Analysis script in the file menu, then browse and add all the images you wish to include, set the analysis method to "Maximum" and away you go. Let the PC chug away and after over an hour you end up with a 22GB temporary Photoshop file and a very large smart object which you should then flatten to a layer for final tweaking.

Comparing the results, the Photoshop version was a little cleaner but Startrails only took 5 minutes to produce the combined images with little memory and temporary file overheads. However if a few number of much longer exposures was used then I'd probably recommend the Photoshop Analysis script approach.


Used in TradeKing Big Dog blog's blog article Friday Community shout-out!.

Featured in Digital Photography Schools blog articleLong Exposure Photography: 15 Stunning Examples.

Reported in Curious? Read's article Long Exposure Photography: 15 Stunning Examples.

Can be found in JASON - HOUSE OF INNOVATION AND CREATIVITY's blog article Fantastic long exposure photos.

Used in The Brown Study blog 2008 Retrospective.

Featured in TheFutureBuzz's article50 Inspirational Images From Flickr Under Creative Commons.

Featured in RRut.com's feature Star Trails: 10 Impressive Photographs.

Featured in the "i tell stories" aricle On Creation: A Quarterly Report - A commitment to learning.

Featured in the WebUrbanist's article 12 Long-Exposure & Time-Lapse Photographers.

Featured in Mr. Topp and the Big Bad Blog's article The morning coffee is all knowing and evil.

Featured in the Slog article Sideral.

Featured in Photography Inspiration.

Used in the Clyde Street blog article 090507 Public Sphere Discussions, Canberra

Used in the Environmental Graffiti article Star Trails: Secret Paintings of the Night Sky.

Featured in Photo Mine.

Featured in Photo Tuts+ piece 50 Captivating Slow Shutter Speed Photos.

Featured in Smash!ng Apps piece 45 Breathtaking Examples of Slow Shutter Speed Photography
This photo has notes. Move your mouse over the photo to see them.

Comments

view profile

eddiemcfish  Pro User  says:

Very nice, and best viewed in large size I'd say. How long / how many exposures did this take?
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

sean_hickin  Pro User  says:

Graet image!

--
Seen on my Flickr home page. (?)
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

monkeyleader  Pro User  says:

Stunning mate - and thanks so much for the explanation. I must give this a blast sometime. The deer incident woud have had me keeling over in shock though :)
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Wiccy ☆  Pro User  says:

Wow, beautiful work and such incredible dedication.
My first thought when I saw this was "awesome, I must have a go at this", after reading your wonderfully clear explanation I decided to leave such technical ideas to the more patient!
Brilliant image, with so much effort gone in to it.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Moldini {fenStudios}  Pro User  says:

Fantastic work Andrew.
Big respect for the patience to capture all the images and braving the cold.
Excellent information. Very inspirational and one that I will definitely try on a still night and away from any deer!
One question.
How do you set it up for continuous frames at 30 sec. Did you set it to manual 30 sec exposure and lock the cable release to always 'pressed' whilst on continuous shutter mode? Does that make sense?
Anyway, big respect and great capture.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

kazam media says:

Lessons learned:
4. Bring a second camera to record the deer incident ;)

Great shot/s, great explanation and I will give this a go soon - cheers
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

loki_p says:

Great shot. I have to stary use light painting.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

.mushi_king  Pro User  says:

Stunning capture and jolly, jolly good effort. Fantastic stuff and thanks for the detailed commetary.

My gosh - rogoue muntjac deer? Maybe it has a flickr account and wanted some action too..?
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

MonketyMonk says:

That's great that is, I really like the light painting of the control tower - that's a nice effect to the overall picture.

Something I really want to have a go at.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Stawarz  Pro User  says:

Thanks everyone, you know when you have an itch and you must scratch it, it also works for photographs when you've a though buzzing in your head.

Jon, yes the camera was set to manual exposure 30 seconds, f/4 and in continuous shoot mode. The shutter was tripped and the remote was set in the locked down position. On the Nikon D300 you're able to set the maximum number of images to shoot in a continuous burst (a maximum of 100). So the camera would automatically stop after 100 continuous shots. I'll update the notes above.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Stawarz  Pro User  says:

Nige, you've got 2 great locations for star trails, St Vigors church and the Windmill on Cambridge Road in Fulbourn. Should be able to get a good North facing vantage. Tempted to stop on Thursday night after the group meet social on the way home if the weather is good (so far not too hopeful, Wednesday and Friday nights look OK but I'm busy on Friday).
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

phojus  Pro User  says:

Nice work Andrew and thanks for the explanation too. I love the bit about the deer bounding in.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Stawarz  Pro User  says:

Thanks Justin, always like to provide an explanation on how pictures that appear odd are done. Normally very straight forward once thought out or researched.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Chopperfoto-leica.torquay says:

This is really stunning, well done
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bbusschots  Pro User  says:

Fantastic star trails shot! Even better considering you were cold and ill!

Bart.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

John Rose Photogrpahy says:

This is awesome, I will definitely have to try it.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

cleangetaway  Pro User  says:

great result and good supporting infor on how this was done, I learnt something here thanks!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

paul (england)  Pro User  says:

So all in all, quite straightforward, then ... ;-)

Absolutely brilliant, Andrew!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

frscspd  Pro User  says:

Wow.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Stawarz  Pro User  says:

Thanks Paul and Marina! Oh very straight forward ;o) just initially time consuming. Been thinking all day about applying the same technique to the following windmill a few away from home:

When the Wind Blows

Would be quite fun to have the swirl between or at the centre of the sails.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Cap'n Surly  Pro User  says:

Great shot, this turned out perfect!! I really need to get a DSLR.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Kirpernicus  Pro User  says:

Great results, well done.

Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Eye Candy!, and we'd love to have this added to the group!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Daniel Cormier  Pro User  says:

Nicely done. Thanks for the tutorial.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Something's Missing  Pro User  says:

Wow, really good.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

zpgoodell  Pro User  says:

Very nice Shot.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

PhilC. says:

Brilliant work!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Johanna Taylor  Pro User  says:

this is beautiful!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Salva Mira  Pro User  says:

Excellent picture. I really like it +++
Congrats
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Katie-Rose  Pro User  says:

Great star trails!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Len Langevin  Pro User  says:

this is a wonderful piece of work!
--
Seen in the interestingness archives. (?)
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

--stevejc--  Pro User  says:

Great shot, brilliantly done!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

. Andrew Dunn . says:

Nicely done. Is there a historical significance behind the choice of foreground?

--
Seen on your photo stream. (?)
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Stawarz  Pro User  says:

Sorry Andrew yes there was, just noticed the one long description has gone missing for some reason, it contained info about the build and a description of the process. Will have to reconstruct it.

Edit: Now done and still scratching my head over how it happened, c'est la vie! Hopefully catch you tonight at the group social Andrew.

Thanks again!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Richie Wisbey  Pro User  says:

Fantastic work.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

paul (england)  Pro User  says:

Please add this to
Slow Photography
(Thanks!)

(This "group" is a mess, I know - I set it up and then did
nothing - but I really will get it sorted out some time ... )
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

grzegorzkomar  Pro User  says:

Absolutely amazing! Great job! Thanx for the story, aswell :)
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Shot12  Pro User  says:

Great shot.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Kai [WSM]™  Pro User  says:

wow. that sounds like a mission. but great, striking result
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

LuisDS  Pro User  says:

Wow! This was really worth the hard work! It is fantastic!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

flofler  Pro User  says:

Thanks for your detailed explanations.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

D.M.Lobo says:

Hola, soy el administrador de un grupo llamado Fotografos Artos de Cerveza y nos encantaría agregar esto al grupo.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Augustin_ says:

brilliant photo, great explanations!
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Alessandro Casagli  Pro User  says:

Awesome pic! Please consider adding it to theWorld's best Nikon shots Group. Cheers! :)
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Paul Forsdick  Pro User  says:

That really does work really well. The house adds a lot to this. Pretty involved but well worth the effort (and the cold!) I think.
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

GranDadWoof  Pro User  says:

I think you're as mad as a bucket of frogs...

... but it was worth it Happy Smileys
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Kumler  Pro User  says:

Fantastic results. And thanks so much for the instructions on how this was done.. I had a good laugh when the deer came out..LOL..

Thanks again,

Andrew
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Mollow2  Pro User  says:

Wonderful shot. Thanks for writing out a step-by-step guide too :)
Posted 14 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Vilhelm Sjostrom  Pro User  says:

Very informative, thanks for tags and thorough description!
Posted 13 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

_J_A_A_K_O_B_  Pro User  says:

Awesome shot! The workflow looks insane to me ;-)
Posted 12 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

stuttgart_san  Pro User  says:

Great description. I only did single shot ong exposures so far. Reading this makes me really want to try the stacking.
Posted 12 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

pbo31  Pro User  says:

Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Light STREAM___, and we'd love to have this added to the group!
Posted 12 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Stuti ~ says:

you are the master.
Posted 12 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

PIXistenz  Pro User  says:

thanks for telling us how you did this... very interesting!
Posted 12 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

flamboyance design (still busy)  Pro User  says:

absolutely stunning!
Posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Tilemahos Efthimiadis  Pro User  says:

It was definately worth the trouble.
Thanks for the tutorial.

Next time have a compact camera ready to capture the Muntjac deer as well :)
Posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

BadMonkeh  Pro User  says:

fantastic concept, a shame about the movement of the trees.

Might have to give this a go myself one day, if i have the patience and fortitude that is ;)
Posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

René Ehrhardt says:

This is a great tut. Thanks for sharing and remember to wear a hat next time ;-)

--
Found in a search. (?)
Posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Debbie Hickey  Pro User  says:

this is great! cant believe it's only 30 second exposure!!!
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

paul (england)  Pro User  says:

No - it's a HUNDRED 30 second exposures, smodje!
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Saloum Photography says:

This is very, very awesome! Well done!
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

eyelenses  Pro User  says:

Awsome
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

delriophoto.com says:

What a great image and thanks for sharing how you did it. The deer crashing into your tripod had me laughing out loud. Thanks again and wonderful shot.
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

⌡K says:

22GB temporary Photoshop file ?!?!!?!?

Nice shot Sir.. and thanks a lot for the description too.
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

JoshChiu  Pro User  says:

could i do this with a D80?!?!?!

i dont think i have that auto 100 shot thing
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Stawarz  Pro User  says:

@Jeesh, I guess you can you it if you put the D80 in continuous shoot mode and use a MC-DC1 (or eBay equivalent) remote cord to lock the shutter down. Looking at page 36 of the D80 manual continuous shooting will stop after 100 shots (the limit is not adjustable like in the D300, D600, D3).

You don't need to take 100 hundred shots to do these, any number will do, the more you take the longer the trails. So as long as you are able to set a long enough exposure, have a continuous shooting mode and have some way of locking the shutter down the above method will work.

I have since been using a MC-36 remote release to give me longer exposure times because the built in intervalvometer in the D300 is restricted to the longest shutter speed of 30 seconds. With the MC-36 I can set a longer exposure time, of say 45 to 60 seconds, and take 200-300 exposures albeit with a 1 second gap between exposures (a limitation in the MC-36 as you have to allow at least a second between exposures).

@JK I was surprised by the temporary file usage of Photoshop but then it is a symptom of Photoshop creating a smart object stack rather than a single blended layer.
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

⌡K says:

I am guessing here that the D80 needs the Nikon Camera Control Pro software and needs to be connected to a laptop with that software for such shots.. Atleast the D60 needs that.
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Stawarz  Pro User  says:

@JK Not for the D80, you would for the D60 as from what I can remember it only allows the use of the IR ML-L3 remote which does not allow for locking the shutter release down.
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

JoshChiu  Pro User  says:

oh ok! i got it now.
thanks for the fast reply.
i have the wireless remote (ML-L3), and thats why i couldnt get it right. i need the cord on like the MC-36.
i also have BULB which can make the shutter speed up to 30 minutes, i believe. would that have the same effect?
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Stawarz  Pro User  says:

@Jeesh, like I said before, invest in a MC-DC1 for your D80 to lock the shutter down in continuous mode.

You could hold the shutter open for 30 minutes in BULB using the ML-L3 to trip open and trip close the shutter. However with longer exposures you are allowing more of the sky to be exposed which is great if you're in the wilds with very little if any light pollution from street lights, head lights and building flood lights.
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

paul (england)  Pro User  says:

But I thought I heard that digital sensors don't work that well for really long exposures like that (compared to film, anyway - although there you have to factor in reciprocity failure). True?
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andrew Stawarz  Pro User  says:

Hi Paul! There are two potential problems when executing long exposures with digital sensors:

1. Highlighting of any dead or stuck pixels that will appear as a few bright random coloured pixels. These would have to be cloned out post processing and if you have a significant number of dead pixels then maybe send the camera in to the manufacturer service centre to have them mapped out.

2. Amplifier noise that will exhibit itself as a glow emanating from a corner or frame edge caused by the on sensor amplifications circuits warming up. Most cameras have a long exposure noise reduction option whereby a second "black frame" (i.e. with the shutter still closed) image of the same exposure duration is automatically taken afterwards so that and noise or amp glow can be masked out from the original shot.
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

paul (england)  Pro User  says:

Thanks very much, Andrew - I learn a lot from you! I'd never even heard of dead pixels or amplifier noise (in photography!) before!
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Nedaa says:

wooooooooow
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

LuisDS  Pro User  says:

I had always wondered why large exposures always take the same amount of time than the exposure itself before they are displayed... It never occurred to me the camera was taking a dark count. Silly me!
Posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

~*Lexi*~ says:

Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Awesome:), and we'd love to have this added to the group!
Posted 8 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

fionaandneil  Pro User  says:

Just found this (my colleague linked me to it after I linked him to your most recent star trails photo!). Amazing amount of dedication to get a wonderful photo!
Posted 7 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

lebit  Pro User  says:

Just an amazing shot
Posted 7 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

nykopix says:

very beautiful
Posted 6 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

TVGuy  Pro User  says:

wonderful
Posted 6 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Seone  Pro User  says:

nice work
Posted 5 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

The Maclac Show  Pro User  says:

Great image, star trails are crisp.
Posted 5 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

P-3O says:

this is art, no matter the whole explanation before the job its done. this is art
Posted 4 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

PanMajster says:

great :)
Posted 4 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Bs0u10e0  Pro User  says:

Great shot and thanks for the write up on the process, i want to try this and was looking for some guidance.
Posted 4 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Tourista de Mancunia  Pro User  says:

Nice shot dude, a man after my own heart both the concept and the procedure, keep up the good work, check out some of my efforts if you get the chance! Cheers Jon
Posted 4 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

sparkfish says:

Great shot and worth the effort.

It's a lot less hassle with film though ;-)
Posted 4 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bobo_xx says:

nice shot. i tried a couple of trail shots, but never managed to find that "sweet spot" that the stars rotate around.
Posted 4 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Zak Milofsky says:

one word: AMAZING
Posted 4 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

dav foto corp. says:

excellent shot and thank you for giving advice before i had to ask for it - the link to startrails is greatly appreciated :)
Posted 4 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Saleh AlRashaid  Pro User  says:

Superb great work my friend !
Posted 3 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

BALIwww.com  Pro User  says:

Great Shot – pls visit my photostream and drop some comment
Go Green Travel - Bali, Indonesia

View my photos at bighugelabs.com

I Gede Sanat Kumara. Get yours at bighugelabs.com/flickr

Go Bali Wedding Services
Posted 3 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

jaosehl (Ashleigh)  Pro User  says:

Awesome shot(s)!
Posted 6 weeks ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bluebox3 says:

Breathtaking and stunning. Thanks!
Posted 6 days ago. ( permalink )

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

[?]

Andrew Stawarz's photostream

1,830
uploads

This photo also belongs to:

Published (Set)

117
items

Bury St Edmunds (Set)

219
items

Explored (Set)

28
items

Star Trails (Set)

8
items

Nikon D300 (Set)

846
items

Sigma 10-20mm f/4-5.6 EX DC HSM (Set)

348
items

Night Images (Pool)

Suffolk (Pool)

FlickrCentral (Pool)

Night Photography (Pool)

After Dark - Night Photography (Pool)

Star Trails (Pool)

Nikon Digital SLRs (Pool)

East Anglia (Pool)

Sigma 10-20mm (Pool)

Nikon D200/D300 Users (Pool)

Nikon DSLR Users (Pool)

A Moment in Time (Pool)

Favorites: 200 (Pool)

Night Sky, The (Pool)

Bury St Edmunds (Pool)

Views: 10000 (Pool)

Eye Candy! (Pool)

Very Long Exposure (30 seconds or more) (Pool)

Light STREAM___ (Pool)

Nikon Digital Learning Center (Pool)

Nikon D300 Users (Pool)

* World's best Nikon shots * (invited pics!) (Pool)

This Week in Photography (Pool)

Slow Photography (Pool)

Fotografos Artos de Cerveza (Pool)

Awesome:) (Pool)

Tags

Click this icon to see all public photos and videos tagged with sky sky

Additional Information

AttributionNo Derivative Works Some rights reserved Anyone can see this photo

Add to your map
Anyone will be able to see this on the map
 (edit)