You aren't signed in     Sign In    Help

An experiment in Twitter carpet following

An experiment in Twitter carpet following by nantel.
I created a new Twitter account that specifically tells people what it's for and not to follow it. I then followed 6000 Twitter feeds over 48 hrs to see who would reciprocate without reading. At last count, it had 137 followers. Interestingly, an additional 83 people initially followed me back, but then read the account description and changed their mind (good!). I also had to block 8 idiots that admitted following RU4Real even though they knew that it was an experiment.

There is no need for you to block the account, it will be deleted once the experiment is over.

Phase 2 officially began once it reached 100 followers. During this period, I won't add anybody else until the weekend to see if I can attract those spam followers that have been annoying everyone.

Finally, I have received some requests to post my real Twitter account. Just don't expect me to blindly follow you back ;-)

[update] I was hoping to close down the account and the experiment this weekend but I have decided to extent it by a week. The main reason is that I haven't been picked up by Twitterholic yet. The other reason is that I am still gathering followers even though I haven't followed anybody since Monday.

[update2] This is nuts, the account has had no activity and no links for months and yet it is still accumulating followers at a rate of 2-6 per day. About to hit the big 500. The 3-month statistics are here.

[update3] After reaching 1001 follower notification in December 2008, I now want to unfollow everyone and see if the account still accumulates followers. I need to find a way of doing this without clicking the remove link >5100 times. 

Comments

view profile

lbstone says:

Robots rule the world.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

kc8zkf says:

How did you choose the feeds to follow?
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

nantel  Pro User  says:

Started with all of the feeds in Twitterholics. After that I would go though the "following" link of whoever would follow me. That's the thing with people that follow 20k people, they are a perfect place to find lots of pages with 20 conveniently aligned "follow" links. I was thus able to follow >2000 feeds without scripting and without too much work.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Anton Peck  Pro User  says:

This is a great idea - I love it. How long will your test go on, and what will you end up doing with the results?

One minor detail I can think of though, is that for some of the more popular accounts that get so many friend requests every day, they either have to:
a) ignore all incoming requests
b) manually manage each request, or
c) auto-add all incoming requests.

They usually just go with the latter. I don't have such a problem with those people as I do the bots. At least until Twitter can include some sort of controllable algorithm that auto-adds a particular criteria.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Jonathan Snook  Pro User  says:

You can have Twitter set up to auto-follow anybody that follows you. I've done this with @snitter. (Follow it and it'll follow you.) You have to contact the devs at Twitter to set this up for you. I suspect with some of the people shown above, this is just the case.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

John So1iman says:

Ya, I usually make it a rule that I don't follow people who are following like 2,000 people but only have like 150 followers. It's really annoying to get that all these follows from advertisers. I'm glad someone finally decided to do a little experiment with this.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

WillowBear says:

Like I just messaged you: I've seen people who follow 4 or 5 thousand, have tweeted maybe two dozen times (terribly lame stuff) yet have 100+ followers.

This could be a social-psych experiment in the making!

--bentrem
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

WillowBear says:

Synch!

Total coincidence: moments after I submitted this comment I found that @kendra2 had followed me. Following 5,790, having tweeted 7 times (including "I set up my Twitter account!), this person has 226 Following.

*head/desk*
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

qthrul  Pro User  says:

It's only going to pick up auto follow most likely... there are a few exceptions.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Weave  Pro User  says:

i know a lot of these guys...they're 4real... also likely in a hurry to add all the follow requests without reading through tweets!
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Foomandoonian  Pro User  says:

I always do a quick check on anyone I might follow and am surprised so many don't seem to. Neat idea.
@foomandoonian
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

justinsfpics says:

yeah, I always gotta check. I get so many company's/blogs I just don't wanna add a nob. @justinsimonsen
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

gRegorLove  Pro User  says:

Ah, the irony of setting up a twitter spam bot to find twitter spam bots :) I blocked it.

As was already pointed out, most of these people have the auto-follow on, and thus never even saw your twitter profile.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

nantel  Pro User  says:

Actually I didn't set-up a spam bot to build my following list, I'm a biologist not a coder. It's the very people that follow thousands of feeds that made my job much easier, I just click on their own "Following" link and I end up with 20 perfectly-aligned "Follow" links. Click, click, click. Go to the next page and click 20 more. Lather, rise, repeat.

This proves that there is actually no use in following >1000 people, other than stroking their ego and pretenting that "I care and I listen". They can't read the resulting torrent of twits and they are certainly not "helping us" by providing a list of helpful/interesting feeds. All they end up creating is the the perfect collecting ground for spammers.

I have seen so many cool internet tools become useless and corrupted. I just don't want this to happen to Twitter.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

nantel  Pro User  says:

How long will the experiment last? Ultimately I'd like to follow about 10k people, enough to make it on the Twitterholic list and really attract the bots. Since I don't use scripting, this may take me about a week. I hope to be able to achieve this before the experiment becomes widely known.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

nantel  Pro User  says:

Just to make sure that I don't catch any "innocent" users of the auto-follow, I will be repeating my "DO NOT FOLLOW" entry every 24 hrs.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

lalunablanca  Pro User  says:

This is great! Very interesting. I recognize a good number of people as well. Some, I thought "yea, it figures". Others, were a bummer to see there.
I ran into an A-Lister at SxSW and I knew who he was because his spouse is a friend, but he has no idea how I am. He looks at my badge, and says, "oh yea, Dave! Good to finally meet you." It was a small insult, and I had previously thought more of the guy.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

2nihon  Pro User  says:

LOL. For the record, I didn't follow. :)
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

illtillwillkillbill  Pro User  says:

Nantel :P

I was wondering who followed me there. Are you those other 10 people per week who follow me and I have never heard of? ;-)

(Well, at least I know who you are!)
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Barbara KB says:

yeah - thanX!
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

mobatalk says:

I follow everyone - it's no big deal.
The bots all grow silent after a little while (well, except for that @br3ndabot) ;^)
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

ACME-Nollmeyer  Pro User  says:

YOU didn't fool ACMEPhoto!

I'm smarter than that! (but we're not sure how much smarter!)
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Steven Ray  Pro User  says:

I could never follow any one with the handle RU4Real... Haha.

One note: RTM is a service, you actually want it to follow you back.
Interesting project non the less.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Ponzarelli  Pro User  says:

I never thought of "following" in this way. I like twitter because of the "discovery" I find through other cool people doing awesome stuff. I do try to read a bit about each person before following. Though I must confess if it happens to be a busy day and I have to choose "follow" back or delete the request I will follow first then delete them later if I find them not real or rude in the "stream of thoughts." I know my husband Chris is on auto follow and uses twitter almost as a replacement for RSS feeds when he's busy. I hadn't thought about the bots, until one attacked me. I had to kill the link between my blog and twitter, someone stole my account and made it twitter tons of blog links. I still haven't figured out either how I accidently did that or someone else did it. Until i do, I won't twitter back to the blog. Interesting experiment on both sides! Good luck!
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

sotonrich  Pro User  says:

OK honesty time.....you added me to twitter and I only checked out your page because the thumbnail was of an attractive looking woman.....if you had a male thumbnail....I probably wouldn't have looked.

There I was honest. *half hangs head in shame* ;P

Maybe this could be a good idea for your your next experiment?
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

nantel  Pro User  says:

Actually she may be a tad too young for that, she's my15 year old daughter.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

LEMills says:

Brilliant use of putting real sociology in the now-trite phrase "social media."

Your secret is safe with me, but after looking at that list, I feel oh-so not special!

Ha!
-Linda
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Anant Jain says:

Good experiment. I always check the pages of those who follow me before I follow them (Unless I know the person personally)
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

noinput  Pro User  says:

i've been on the instant-follow kick for about a week, i usually roll through all the follows then open profiles in new tabs to check people out. a bit twisted but im all about GTD when i can do it.

amazing timing.. after i followed you, i removed the follow once i read the tweet about the experiment, and i noticed twitter went down. however it didn't take.

*shame*

im on your list of bots, yet i'm a real boy.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Agitproper  Pro User  says:

I've been pretty good about checking too... VERY cool work!
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Frank Jonen says:

you also hide your twitter url from the public. only the link to this flickr is visible in 3rd party apps.

Is there a reason that you don't play fair in this?
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Frank Jonen says:

but thanks for the google juice anyway :)
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

nantel  Pro User  says:

> you also hide your twitter url from the public. only the link to this flickr is visible in 3rd party apps.

Actually I didn't know that since I don't use 3rd party apps to read Twitter, I get interrupted often enough as it is. I don't know if you noticed but the only favorite on the RU4Real account takes you to my own Tweet announcing the experiment. Finally, my own Twitter feed is linked in the image description on Flickr.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

losangelestimes  Pro User  says:

Congrats nantel on creating a mini web meme. Instead of getting Rickrolled, folks now can get RU4Real-rolled.

Sounds like a phenomena our Web Scout blog would report on.

- LAT
Posted 8 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

LEMills says:

During the recent dust-up about blocking people who send "thanks for the follow" by auto-DM, I wandered back to this picture to see if complainers are auto-followers.... Wouldn't that be interesting.... -Linda
Posted 5 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

WillowBear says:

And more: I suspect there's some way to game Twitter. Not often, even rarely, I've seen accounts that have neither name nor URL and yet ... get ready ... have many thousands of followers. I mean it. The one that comes to mind had over 7K. *shrug*

May the spirit of RU4Real live long!
:-)
Posted 5 months ago. ( permalink )

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

[?]
view photos Uploaded on April 13, 2008
by nantel

nantel's photostream

2,664
uploads

Tags

Additional Information

All rights reserved Anyone can see this photo

  • Taken on April 17, 2008
  • 4 people call this photo a favorite
  • Viewed 2,391 times
  • Replaced on April 17, 2008
Add to your map