Andromeda, again.

Due to the considerable noise in my earlier post, I decided to acquire new data. I made some changes, and managed to get better magnification. I'm really quite thrilled about this!

Unlike my previous attempt, this one actaully looks better in All Sizes.

To take full advantage of Flickr, you should use a JavaScript-enabled browser and
install the latest version of the Macromedia Flash Player.

Comments

noonespillow [deleted] says:

Tis beautiful..
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

grrlscout says:

It's awesome. Really amazing.
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

jpstanley says:

Nice dust lanes, and the stars are tack-sharp. Looks like the use of the bandage to hold the lens at 300mm was effective.

Which shots did you end up using? Before or after removing the dew-covered UV filter?
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

Viorica G says:

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW!
FANTASTIC SHOT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hugs and fave
Have an AMAZING WEEK my friend :)

Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

dezsö [deleted] says:

found in flickr’s explore interestingness, a favourite...well done!

flickr.com/explore/interesting/7days/
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

Thanks folks!

Jeremy - lol. Yeah, the bandage did the trick! I ended up using the best 8 (or so) images. They were all shots that didn't have the UV filter.
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

Steiner62 (An Animal & his Anima) says:

The World Through My Eyes
Wish I could do this with my gear - great work...
www.flickr.com/groups/outofthisworld/
Join my group!
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

ehoyer says:

wow! beautiful shot.

--
Seen in The World Through My Eyes - Post 2 / Comment Any 1 (?)
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

LostPizzaBoy says:

Front page of explore always has beautiful shots, but this hits a real chord with me. Well done.
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

Gallo Quirico says:

Beautiful M31

--
<
Seen on the explore page. (?)
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

chipdatajeffb says:

You should be VERY happy with this, it's a keeper! Great job, Brian!
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

wagsdot911 says:

my mouth dropped on this one.. amazing! Good job!
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

daniel shiu says:

Wow! fantastic!
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

The positive reaction is really exciting. I'm glad so many enjoyed this!

LostPizza - Did you see this on the front page of explore?!

Jeff - Thanks. It's been a tricky target for me, but I managed to work out the kinks. I'm glad you approve. Your work is an inspiration to me.

wags - Thanks for this and all your other nice comments.
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

Gronson says:

Fantastic!
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

Breno Peck says:

You made that with a 300mm lens?

How did you manage to get so close?! Is this a crop?
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

DayTripper (Tom) says:

That shot is awesome!!! Just beautiful!!!
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

Breno - It's not much of a crop, actually (though a little - ~10% maybe). The object is just that big!

It spans an enormous 3(plus) full degrees in the sky - more than 6 full moons across. That is really saying something considering that it is 2.5 million light years away - "unimaginably gigantic" isn't even close to a sufficient description.
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

SteelePop [deleted] says:

that is truely amazing

--
Seen on your photo stream. (?)
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

mblaz says:

wow fantastic shot!

If you want you can post your picture in our new group
Virtual Picture Presentation
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

bksecretphoto says:

Great shot and working out the kinks. Quite an image concidering you took it though the atmosphere. ;-)
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

Bk - Thanks! Yeah, I should try standing on my toes, next time. Actually, I was at an elevation of 6600 feet when I acquired this shot, so it could have been worse, huh?
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

tr1307 says:

Great shot of M31. Definitly a favourite.
Must get a clocked drive some day.

{1:1:1}
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

copeg says:

Great shot! With a 300mm?!? Dang. And looking at your other shot and what you went through for that one, wow. Very well done! I applaud you.
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

tr1307 - Thanks! Glad you like it.

copeg - I really appreciate that. These shots are more involved than most people realize. Thanks for noticing!
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

davesbit says:

very cool, nice clear night, looks like your tracking was dead on!
great shot!
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

dewaperang vol.2 says:

cuantikk....=beautifull..;)
Posted 39 months ago. ( permalink )

kostaki says:

Absolutely amazing. You did one hell of a job eliminating the noise over your previous attempt. How did you do it. This is beautiful!

You just used a 300mm lens? Possibly the the standard 75-300mm zoom from Canon?
Posted 38 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

Thanks! I'm not sure how consicely I can relay what I did, but I'll try.

I have the 70-300mm IS lens. In the first image, I used the lens at the 70mm setting. Why? Because when you extend the lens to the 300mm position, and then point the lens up and let go, then the weight of the glass causes it to retract to the 70mm position. Somewhat inconveniently, most of the stars are "up." This resulted in some heavy cropping in post-process.

On my next outing, I bought some self-adhesive compression bandage (the kind that a doctor would apply to keep gauze in place) and wrapped it around my lens in the 300mm position. That way 30-40% of the CCD chip was catching photons from Andromeda, instead of the 5% I got before. That cuts waaaay down on the noise since I'm using more pixels to 'describe' the image
Posted 38 months ago. ( permalink )

Danny Flippo says:

Nice image!
Posted 38 months ago. ( permalink )

Leviathor says:

I've faved and tagged this one "QUALITY" and am hoping you will join and post it to:

www.flickr.com/groups/quality_photography/

where photographic quality such as this gets the recognition it deserves and inspires others...

QUALITY!

Please read (and heed) the comment entitled"YOUR Responsibility" on the Group's opening page.

--
Seen on your photo stream. (?)
Posted 38 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

Leviathor - I'm honored by the invite. It's been added.
Posted 38 months ago. ( permalink )

madcurtis says:

cograts on this wonderful shot of andromeda, i have never had a bit of luck on this one it's just to big.
Posted 37 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

Thanks, madcurtis. I struggled with it for a while, too.
Posted 37 months ago. ( permalink )

anthonyarrigo98 says:

Sweet Shot.
Where'd you take this from?
Posted 35 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

AA - I took this from the parking lot of a city park in Bountiful, Utah.
Posted 35 months ago. ( permalink )

iamunknown_wiki says:

It is very beautiful, I'm glad you were able to take the photograph while still in a city. And thank you very much for licensing this image as CC-BY-2.0. Your photograph is now uploaded to Wikimedia Commons, a database of freely reusable media files, where it can be used by Wikipedia or other free content projects. Again, thank you!
Posted 31 months ago. ( permalink )

ComputerHotline says:

Cyrus says:

stunning shoot !!!!!!!!!!
Posted 24 months ago. ( permalink )

surfelixe says:

can i do the same with my sony alpha 100?? great photo the besttt =)
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

surfelixe - The short answer is 'yes.' The real answer is 'yes, with the right equipment.' You'd need a telephoto lens (on the order of 300mm) and some way to accommodate the motion of the sky (which is magnified when you zoom in).

It's simple in concept, difficult in practice. Some of the obstacles are the following: You have to have some way to track the object you're trying to capture since it can take minutes or hours to get usable images (due to the relative faintness of stars and distant galaxies). In this case, my 20D was on an equatorial telescope mount with a built in motor which turns at the same rate as the sky. It's also surprisingly hard to focus in the dark. It's also hard to find dark place since most cities are now overrun by light pollution, obscuring the night sky and wasting billions in electricity. Also, once you've captured the images, you'll want to do some photoshop work since they'll be rather 'noisy' images, and probably quite faint. All this, and say nothing of needing clear skies on a moonless night during the time of year that the object you want to capture is high in the sky.

If you're interested in dabbling in astrophotography, start by shooting a full moon. You'll just need a telephoto lens. It's bright enough that you can autofocus on it, and you can get a great exposure with only a tripod - or hand-held if you've a steady hand.
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

surfelixe says:

obrigado makelessnoise! mas tenho mesmo de comprar uma lente de 300mm? eu tenho um telescopio o astromaster 70EQ que dá para ligar á makina com t adapter e t ring com Focal Length de
900mm. é possivel tirar a foto a partir daí? e existe esse tipo de motor para qualquer telescopio para virar ao mesmo tempo do céu?
já agora sou de Portugal e tu? brasil?

obrigado
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

ComputerHotline says:

Thanks for licensing this image as CC "by" !
Your photo is uploaded here :
commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Image:Brian_-_Andr omeda%2C_aga...
under the terms of the Creative Commons "by" license.

--
http://flickrcc.bluemountains.net/index.php?t erms=&edit=yes&com=yes&page=1 (?)
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

surfelix - Nao e' preciso que compre uma lente assim. Uma coisa importante e' que Andromeda e' GRANDE. Egual a seis lunas cheias lado ao lado. Um telescopio de 900mm nao iria contem Andromeda entirinho. Com respeito ao motor pra sue telescopio, depende na fabricador dele. Boa sorte, amigo.

Sou Norte Americano. Faz mais que dez anos que morei em Brasil, e Eu estava la por dois anos, so. Por isso meu Portuguese e' um poco estranho - faz muito tempo que nao escrevo nessa lingua. ;)
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

surfelixe says:

mas escreves muito bem!=) parabens! obrigado
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

Megharah says:

awesome shot! im green with envy :D:D:D

But.. why u hide the EXIF?? im very curious, anyway, its wonderful!
Posted 22 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

Meghara - Thanks! I'm glad you like it. The EXIF isn't present because that image is not a single exposure. I stacked several frames in photoshop, which lost the EXIF data. If I remember correctly, it was 32 exposures of 30 seconds @ 800 ISO. The aperture would have been about f/5.6 or so. Thanks for asking!
Posted 22 months ago. ( permalink )

aldarain says:

Your Skies album is fantastic , congratulations... :)
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

Aldarain - Thank you! I'm very pleased you like it.
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

gregpphoto says:

AstroP is crazy and you do it really well.

"It's also hard to find dark place since most cities are now overrun by light pollution, obscuring the night sky and wasting billions in electricity."

Yea, someone should go all fight club on them, like at the end. It's absolutely ridiculous this country wastes, and we're all individually guilty as well, but still, it's sad and it shouldn't be allowed to happen. At least you don't live at the butt-nature capital of the country where I do. I'm stuck in between Philly and NYC, right in the middle of smog-america New Jersey. There's nights where I see only a handfull of stars :(
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

gp - thank you! Yeah, light pollution is just a bane. Sounds like you're in the most light polluted corridor on the continent.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

Samurai Blur says:

This Galaxy will fill the night sky of earth in 5 million years. Can you think how well we could see it through a telescope if we were still around??!! Great shot!
Posted 12 months ago. ( permalink )

makelessnoise says:

Samurai - If we *are* around, I hope we've at least got a handle on the light pollution problem! Thanks!
Posted 12 months ago. ( permalink )

jpstanley says:

A small nitpick - In 5 million years, Andromeda won't actually look noticeably bigger. The galaxy is moving toward us a 300 kilometers per second. While that sounds fast, keep in mind that light travels 1000 times faster, and it takes light 2.5 million years to get here (since it's 2.5 Mly away). That means, at this rate, M31 will collide with ours in about 2.5 billion years. In five million years, it will have completed only 0.2% of that journey.
Posted 12 months ago. ( permalink )

Eddi 07(OFF) says:

Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Creative Commons- Free Pictures, and we'd love to have this added to the group!
Posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )

subha.e says:

Thanks for sharing this photo. I used this, attributed to you, in one of my articles.
newage.suite101.com/article.cfm/is_the_world_ going_to_be_...
If any questions or concerns, please let me know.
Thank you :-)
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

Would you like to comment?

[?]

	makelessnoise's photostream
		781 uploads

This photo also belongs to:

	Top Shots (Set)
		73 items

	The Skies (Set)
		107 items

	Night Images (Pool)
		0

	Astrophotography (Pool)
		0

	After Dark - Night Photography (Pool)
		0

	Astronomy (Pool)
		0

	1-2-3 (Pool)
		0

	Canon 20D (Pool)
		0

	Gazing Into Outer Space (Pool)
		0

	National Geographic Wannabes (Pool)
		0

	Outstanding Night Shots- 15 or more faves only (Pool)
		0

	ThE sKy'S tHe LiMiT (Pool)
		0

	Quality -- Best of the Best -- (Invitation ONLY) (Pool)
		0

	*GreatPixGallery 20 Faves+ (Pool)
		0

	*GreatPixGallery 50 Faves+ (Pool)
		0

	Awesome Nature (Pool)
		0

	The World Through My Eyes - Post 1 / Comment Any 1 (Pool)
		0

	Looking to the sky, whats above for all to see (Pool)
		0

	{1:1:1} (Pool)
		0

104 people call this photo a favorite

Additional Information

Some rights reserved Anyone can see this photo

Taken on February 20, 2009
Viewed 13,743 times
Replaced on February 20, 2009

Add to your map

Yay location removed

...

(Some formats are OK.)

Or, remove it from the map.

Go to the map

You	Sign in \| Create Your Free Account
Explore	Places \| Last 7 Days \| This Month \| Popular Tags \| The Commons \| Creative Commons \| Search
Help	Community Guidelines \| The Help Forum \| FAQ \| Sitemap \| Get Help

Andromeda, again.

Comments

noonespillow [deleted] says:

grrlscout says:

jpstanley says:

Viorica G says:

dezsö [deleted] says:

makelessnoise says:

Steiner62 (An Animal & his Anima) says:

ehoyer says:

LostPizzaBoy says:

Gallo Quirico says:

chipdatajeffb says:

wagsdot911 says:

daniel shiu says:

makelessnoise says:

Gronson says:

Breno Peck says:

DayTripper (Tom) says:

makelessnoise says:

SteelePop [deleted] says:

mblaz says:

bksecretphoto says:

makelessnoise says:

tr1307 says:

copeg says:

makelessnoise says:

davesbit says:

dewaperang vol.2 says:

kostaki says:

makelessnoise says:

Danny Flippo says:

Leviathor says:

makelessnoise says:

madcurtis says:

makelessnoise says:

anthonyarrigo98 says:

makelessnoise says:

iamunknown_wiki says:

ComputerHotline says:

*Cyrus* says:

surfelixe says:

makelessnoise says:

surfelixe says:

ComputerHotline says:

makelessnoise says:

surfelixe says:

Megharah says:

makelessnoise says:

aldarain says:

makelessnoise says:

gregpphoto says:

makelessnoise says:

Samurai Blur says:

makelessnoise says:

jpstanley says:

Eddi 07(OFF) says:

subha.e says:

Would you like to comment?

Tags

Additional Information

Cyrus says: