You aren't signed in     Sign In    Help

The Cellist

The Cellist by bdmckeown.
As I was walking down the street, I saw this man playing absolutely beautiful cello music outside of the gates of the Mormon Tabernacle in Salt Lake City, Utah. It was the end of the annual convention at the Tabernacle, and a large, bustling crowd was pouring from the large concrete gate which surrounded the tabernacle. I closed my eyes for a moment and listened to the perfection coming from his cello strings. Laid open at the man's feet was his old cello case, acting as a humble request for monitary compensation. I peered in the case, and to my dissapointment, I found that only a few single dollar bills had been offered. It seemed quite ironic to me that men and women of such seemingly privelaged status (elegant suits, ties, and dresses were on each person) declined to offer anything to this man. Those who were exiting hardly even turned their ears to listen. However, about 100 feet away from the cellist, a young, elegantly clad violinist was playing equally beautiful music with his case open at his feet. This sharp young violinist truly looked as if he belonged within the gates. In essence, one could surmise that this violinist didn't need any money. A crowd had gathered around him to close their eyes and bob their heads to the sounds of his instrument. There must have been $200 in his open case. Back at the other street corner, the cellist (pictured here) seemed to be oblivious to the cold shoulders by which he was so often greeted.
I wondered about the symbolism of this scenario - privelaged persons exiting a massive temple surrounded by an impenetrable wall...and a poor man outside the gates, dirty and unshaven, to whom no one will offer even a listening ear. See if you think (like I do) that this cello playing man shares some uncanny resemblance to the historically accepted image of another church figure. Just a thought. 

Comments

← prev 1 2
(173 comments)
view profile

PenguinsInTheDesert says:

Only you can capture a story within a picture as well as you do.
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

slight clutter  Pro User  says:

Exceptional photo with a terrific narrative to go along with it! :)
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

deVos  Pro User  says:

Wow, what a great picture and such a captivating story! Thanks for sharing it!
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bdmckeown  Pro User  says:

Thank you all for the comments. My favorite pictures are ones that tell stories. This one was simply breathtaking. I knew I was photographing something special while I was there. Thanks a bunch.
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Jan Tik says:

Gorgeous picture and a sad but wonderful story. It reminds me of the parable of the good Samaritan, where the priests and the regular churchgoers ignored the injured man.
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Mansour says:

Did you get the chance to talk to him?
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bdmckeown  Pro User  says:

Yes, in fact, I did. His voice was scratchy and high; I could detect a small lisp (probably a product of his poorly maintained teeth). He told me that he was one of the most photographed parts of Salt Lake City, and that he'd been sitting in this same spot playing the cello regularly for something like 12 years. He never mentioned anything about the ignorance he recieved. Some small part of me thinks it was because he liked being unusual. But ultimately, it was his cello that did the talking. I closed my eyes and could easily imagine myself in a grand concert hall, listening to a cellist of equally grand stature. The juxtaposition of such wonderfully beautiful music coming from such an old, worn cello was equally as impressive as the juxtaposition of the cellist and his surroundings. It was nothing short of breathtaking.
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

sho0t says:

wonderful picture, full of life and sadness
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Daniele Florio  Pro User  says:

Thanks for sharing it!
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

hockadilly  Pro User  says:

That's a beautiful portrait; your description of meeting him is even more beautiful.

Reminds me of The Messiah: "A man of sorrow, and acquainted with grief."
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

t-squared  Pro User  says:

A sad story well told. It rings completing true to me as I'm familiar with the people involved. They are comfortable only with their own.
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Bobby Alcott  Pro User  says:

The very best social commentary I've ever seen. Just simply brilliant. THANK YOU.
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

lorayne  Pro User  says:

An excellent thought, very beautiful and touching....unless, of course, the cellist is actually quite well off and his poor apprearance is his hook. I would believe he is sincere though and am seriously considering making his corner a stop on my next vacation so I can put something in his cello case.
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Violentz  Pro User  says:

wow! what a beautiful image!
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Martin Cathrae  Pro User  says:

That look you captured is awesome.
Posted 59 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Zamboni says:

The photo and commentary are brilliant...and you're right on the money. There isn't anything about Christianity that says give only to those that you can relate to...
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

A-Wix  Pro User  says:

He's playing so intently that it looks like he might cry. Out of love for those who snub him?
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bdmckeown  Pro User  says:

I think he might just be so full that he's overflowing. Of what, I don't know.
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Martin Cathrae  Pro User  says:

I think he's overflowing with awesomeness!
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

ssh says:

This pic is just worth millions. Am still on a trip with the man listening to what he plays. But all i hear is Georgia on my mind. Plus the feelings of the wonderful man.

I never belived the quote which says " A picture is worth thousand of words" which made me to belive it today right now at this very momment.

Just belive it or not. This picture really speaks ( Goosebumps all over me body) :)
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

nonie vogue  Pro User  says:

An awesome photo, and the commentary makes it even more so. thanks for sharing.
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

vice1  Pro User  says:

That's such an amazing shot Ben, you can really feel the emotion.
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

vrot [deleted] says:

.........stunning.......
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Giant Ginkgo  Pro User  says:

What a beautiful, tragic looking shot. I'm quite amazed.
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

aqui-ali  Pro User  says:

bdmckeown: lovely story. I appreciate that you take a look at these things and take time to share it with us.

Great shot too..
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

basykes  Pro User  says:

You're right--that's a beautiful story to go with an outstanding photograph. I have to admit I've never seen someone play the cello with mittns on before!
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

javajive  Pro User  says:

Phenomenal capture. The addition of your words enhances the image 10-fold. Bravo.
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

lotusutol  Pro User  says:

beautiful story... somehow i like his expression in the photo too, sorta like he's still enjoying playing the cello despite the circumstances. =)
Posted 58 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

hendriko  Pro User  says:

This might just be my absolute favorite picture/story that I have come across on Flickr so far. I love it a lot.
Posted 57 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

mark lorch  Pro User  says:

genius, just a marvelous picture and very moving. thank you
Posted 57 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

waxpancake  Pro User  says:

Nobody stopped to hear him
Though he played so sweet and high
They knew he had never
Been on their T.V.
So they passed his music by

I meant to go over and ask for a song
Maybe put on a harmony
I heard his refrain
As the signal changed
He was playing real good for free
Posted 57 months ago. ( permalink )

rAndoM AliAs [deleted] says:

This is outstanding. His eyes speak volumes!
Exceptional work.
Posted 57 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Ichor  Pro User  says:

Amazing shot. This is so good!
Posted 57 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Lola Lyndon: Stone Cold Fox! says:

Such is life.

How very eloquently expressed...
Posted 57 months ago. ( permalink )

fipi [deleted] says:

great face, great story.
Posted 57 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

patrickw  Pro User  says:

Wow! I was really intrigued by the photo, amazing expression and feeling, but got chills reading your story. Very moving image and story!
Posted 57 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Venerable Kalense  Pro User  says:

the look on his face seems to mix rapture and agony. you captured him in such an exquisite moment. somehow those dirty gloves help to make the photo vibrate with the sound of the cello. lovely detail in his face. beautiful photo. i hope he finds what he is looking for.
Posted 56 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

ACreepingMalaise  Pro User  says:

Great picture!
Posted 56 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Dr. Fujitronic - NO YAHOOLIGAN says:

This looks almost like a theatre scene, but I believe the expression is authentic. He seems to know suffering. (Catweasle and JC come to mind)
As a sidenote: I have been busking in the past and learned, that an experienced busker never leaves large amounts of money visible in his case.(for obvious reasons;
it's safer and you get even more money!)
K.kid said: hope, he finds his way... he propably already did; we just have to let him be. And of cause sponsor those folks, be it only for the great photo op., they provide.
Touching picture, fav'ed.
Posted 56 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Alton @flickr  Pro User  says:

Bravo, busker. Bravo, photographer.
Posted 56 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Matt Niebuhr  Pro User  says:

I'm wondering if the image would stand on its own without the subtext explanations...?
Posted 56 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bdmckeown  Pro User  says:

mniebuhr, it probably wouldn't be as impactful. However, I think that the entire essence of the situation is what I was hoping to capture. There are subtextual nuances that can just not be illustrated through the photo. So, to answer your question, I've wondered the same thing, and I think that the image would be a little less impactful. However the moment is what I was trying to capture.
Posted 56 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

eliadee says:

Story or not, I find the shot itself striking. There you captured so much of Life and its irony in a nutshell... My eyes are watery now but I'm no sad... it is just that the virtuoso moves me dramatically and I feel so close to him. You felt the same, didn't you? Unique!
Posted 56 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Alton @flickr  Pro User  says:

An axiom of storytelling: 'Show, don't tell.' A picture draws us in more effectively when we aren't told what we're supposed to feel.

You can trust an image like this. It tells its own story.
Posted 56 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Matt Niebuhr  Pro User  says:

I think the image when looking at independently, happens to benefit from the depth of the "story" - the image on its own is OK ... That said, I still really like the image - it captures some emotion, wistfulness pondering..., but I'm left feeling like I'm being tricked perhaps.... I wonder too about how t(his) story could be told (extended in depth) in a series of shots - context.
Posted 56 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

razorbern  Pro User  says:

great narrative, great shot my friend
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Mike In Park City says:

I like this photo very much. The expression on the man's face is showing his deep love for music.

As for the commentary, I have to say that even though all these "nicely dressed" church goers are passing him by, doesn't mean they are ignoring him. I have lived in Salt Lake City, the "homeless" people are on every corner, bench, and sidewalk around the Mormon Temple. These church goers see them every day and give them money all the time. Like you said, he has been there for 12 years. Please don't down play the church people based on one visit.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

Liisa [deleted] says:

fabulous image capturing so much in it.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bdmckeown  Pro User  says:

twentyfives...I understand what you're saying. My impressions aren't surmised based on only one visit. I grew up in the chuch. Both of my parents have been ministers in many different churches. My assertion is that if we were to take Jesus' message seriously, being well dressed in the presence of a poorly dressed, homeless person would be wrong. Jesus taught a life that involved giving the needy everything you own, even the clothes on your back. That's the thing that irked/irks me about Christianity. Hypocrisy is rampant. I believe that if Jesus (whether you believe him to be a real or fabricated character) were to see the things we do in his name, He'd be distraught.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Mike In Park City says:

Thanks bdmckeown for your clarification. I agree with you 100% about your comment about Hypocrisy. Your photo is very emotional and is one of my fav's. Thanks again.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bdmckeown  Pro User  says:

No problem. And just to clarify, my comment wasn't intended to be taken in any sort of offensive or malicious way. Just like you said, it was simply a clarification. I welcome and enjoy thoughtful discussion about these kinds of topics. And I'm so happy you like the picture.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

.Laura (jwb's mom) says:

So beautiful. I love his eyes.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Esther17  Pro User  says:

Telling photo and story. His expression is entrancing.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Ten Directions  Pro User  says:

I know this place and culture all to well and have been where this photo was taken many times. It does not surprise me he would be ignored by the predominant culture there.

How can one not have compassion for this man.

This is a great photo. One of the best I have seen.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

purplezebra  Pro User  says:

The narrative really adds to this photo. Great work.
Posted 53 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

MigMimo says:

excelent shot!! very powerful
Posted 53 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

r0semary  Pro User  says:

Absolutely amazing! Great job!
Posted 53 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

waynemethod  Pro User  says:

look at that expression. Excellent catch. congratulation.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

David Maddison says:

Amazing, his story looks etched on his face
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

aliasgrace  Pro User  says:

Stunning.
Posted 51 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

svejk57 says:

I love the photo - my favourite on flickr. Such expressiveness and beautiful light - thanks for the story too!
Posted 50 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

vagabondrhythm says:

Very nice. Another pool for this:
One Face @ a Time ~ Street Portraiture www.flickr.com/groups/77128121@N00/
Posted 50 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

dalydose says:

The picture by itself stands alone only to be enhanced by the verbage you've chosen to attach to it.
Posted 50 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

cutglassdecanter says:

what a lot to think about..
Posted 50 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

vagabondrhythm says:

Oh, and another group suggestion:
Street Performers: www.flickr.com/groups/keepitstreet/
Posted 50 months ago. ( permalink )

inamillion [deleted] says:

great shot great story very sad
Posted 49 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Lycurgo C. Querido  Pro User  says:

Beautiful portrait, great story.
Posted 49 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

one43 says:

Instant favorite - Superb light, wonderful framing, superior subject = a perfect portrait. Thank you!
Posted 49 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

HopeHubris  Pro User  says:

This is a good picture made even more inspiring by the narrative. Terrific work
Posted 48 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

filmsaboutghosts says:

I quite enjoyed this anecdote, despite the plight of this wonderful cellist. I've always preferred cellists to violinists, anyway.
Posted 48 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Or Hiltch  Pro User  says:

Awesome photo, an instant favourite ;)
Posted 48 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

SPH says:

Amazing picture. You captured his expression wonderfully.
Posted 48 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

dlemieux  Pro User  says:

wow...very moving. that's quite a story.
i would have stood and listened.
Posted 47 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

diamonds_in_the_soles_of_her_shoes  Pro User  says:

Khalil Gibran said: " Your clothes conceal much of your beauty, yet they hide not the unbeautiful. "
Posted 47 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

bdmckeown  Pro User  says:

gio... Beautiful. My favorite book of all time is "The Prophet" by Gilbran.
Posted 47 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Bob Rosenbaum says:

great photo/story but that is a bass not a cello...
Posted 47 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

edwinsail  Pro User  says:

You've captured not only the often sad ethos of Salt Lake City and its Temple environs, but the stark beauty of this man and his cello. Bravo!
Posted 47 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Inj  Pro User  says:

STUNNING work, bdmckeown. A flower blooming unseen is no less beautiful, I say.
This image resonates with so many on some level--a tribute to secret sorrow or to confident faith in the face of no evidence? I'd guess this guy is more spiritual than most.
Posted 47 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

idle a while  Pro User  says:

Amazing detail. <3 Beautiful work.
Posted 47 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Joel Mancuso  Pro User  says:

I love the image. I once live in SLC and I use to see this man often. I suppose expected to see him any time I went down town. Afer seening him so much, I had several conversations with him about his past, music, and weather.
Since I moved, I never think of him. But your images blasted me back to a time that i am very fond of. thank you so much.
Posted 47 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Digit-Ized  Pro User  says:

It is funny how one comes accross images on Flickr. I'm skipping thrpugh some of BarryBar's pictures and I see one of your comments, I click and ... here I am.

An instant fave. For the quality of the picture, the story and the wisdom that come from the man's eyes.
Posted 46 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

don't wait for me says:

Inspiring.
Posted 46 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

mikyduj says:

this photo (and the story behind it) is beautiful.
Posted 45 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Happy Tinfoil Cat  Pro User  says:

Living in SLC area for half my life, this story is a fitting illistration of the culture there. Perhaps this man could be the resurected Christ, coming in the night like a thief.
Posted 45 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Aradan  Pro User  says:

This is a very beautiful photo. I love the light in his eyes.
Posted 45 months ago. ( permalink )

ramonadixon [deleted] says:

what a moving photograph. and the narrative made it come alive. thank you for sharing it.
Posted 45 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

naughton321  Pro User  says:

Simply fabulous!
Posted 45 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Thoughtful says:

Unbelievably Believable!!
Posted 45 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

sanbeiji  Pro User  says:

Great photo. I think this is actually a double bass, not a cello, based on the size of the neck and scroll, and the fact that it has tuning machines (which I've never seen on a cello, but are standard on basses). Love the narrative too.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Vol-au-Vent  Pro User  says:

Hi, was searching for 'music' (most interesting...) and your wonderful cello player turned up immediately.... How extraordinary! I am playing the cello too but NOT with gloves. How on earth can anybody play with gloves and obviously play beautifully too?
An instant fave; and WHAT a story - probably everybody wrote the same but haven't got the time now to read everything. Thank you for this gift!
Posted 43 months ago. ( permalink )

abhayah~ [deleted] says:

His eyes! Incredible how in the silent dimension of your photograph I can hear the music. Those lovely rich warm string tones. Favourite.
Posted 43 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Michael Godek says:

wow...yes wonderful story....so often i pass up people on the streets...and to think of all of the blessings that i have and that people such as this cellist seem to get the point of life...while i try and make money and get frustrated with material things i forget about what life really is, and actually living it

this man, just the look in his eyes shows care for what he is doing, he loves playing no matter what people think or express...he lives life and is passionate....i donno, it probably doesn't make any sense but this is a very touching picture! simply a beautiful image!!!
Posted 42 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

emmy75 says:

Matthew 25:40 'I tell you the truth, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers of mine, you did for me.'

Beautiful picture, speaks volumes. Your narrative is a wonderful lesson. I pray I can learn from it and everyone else who reads it. Thank you so much. -Emily
Posted 42 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

MicheleMoricci says:

Love this pic. Great.
Love the words,too.
Thank u for sharing. MIK
Posted 42 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

astropaints  Pro User  says:

Wow I just got the chills......I lived in SLC and moved away about 3 years ago. I vividly remember this guy, he is absolutely amazing. I remember listening to him for extended periods of time whenever I was downtown. Thanks for bringing back this memory. :)
Posted 42 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

_scott_ says:

Wow. perfect representation of the starving artist.

Very nice shot.
Posted 42 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Felipe Navarro V. says:

what a beautiful picture!
Posted 42 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

en.tro.py  Pro User  says:

His expression is fantastic! Wonderfully captured!
Posted 41 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Mike Morgan2005  Pro User  says:

Great picture - saw it last night and I reflected on it all night. This morning, however, I woke thinking about your comments about the Mormons' supposed lack of concern for him or 'people not like him'. My thoughts turned to previous posts relating to how long he'd been there (12 years). My assumption would be he'd move on if he was getting nothing. Also, I got to thinking about the humanitarian efforts of the church. Are you aware of these? They are typically the first in with food, water, clothing, help, etc. whenever and whereever there is a need. I know it's their website, but you can get a glimpse of these efforts at www.lds.org/ldsfoundation/accelwork/humaninte reststory/0,... or simply do a google search for other non-biased stories.
Posted 41 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

PhilWestcott  Pro User  says:

a quite confusing facial expresseion from this man. I love it though, gives you a few different ideas as to what he could be thinking about.
Posted 41 months ago. ( permalink )

← prev 1 2
(173 comments)

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

[?]
view photos Uploaded on February 28, 2005
by bdmckeown

bdmckeown's photostream

1,561
uploads

This photo also belongs to:

Faces (and the rest of people) (Set)

309
items

My Best Stuff (According to both me and you) (Set)

71
items

Fine Art Definitely (Set)

27
items

Photojournalism Portfolio (Set)

20
items

From The Archives (Set)

44
items

Far Away Places (Set)

19
items

Emotions (Pool)

FlickrCentral (Pool)

Story Project (Pool)

Only One (Pool)

Expressions and Stories (Pool)

Pictures With Stories - 5 sentence MINIMUM (Pool)

10 seconds (Pool)

Top-V, The Original 'Top Views' Group (Pool)

top-f [ 25+ faves ] (Pool)

World Culture (Pool)

unposed (Pool)

Poverty (Pool)

Writing You Inspire (Pool)

Street Music (Pool)

A View of Music (Invitation Only) (Pool)

Tags

Additional Information

All rights reserved Anyone can see this photo

Add to your map