You aren't signed in     Sign In    Help

Language Has Failed Us.

Language Has Failed Us. by AnomalousNYC.
An Israeli Occupation Soldier, hand on gun, screams at a Palestinian father and his child. The man is risking a beating and arrest to come near the construction site, and many such as him have already been killed by soldiers along the Wall's construction route. And yet the entire village has come out with him, the elderly and the young, along with a handfull of courageous and progressive Israelis and Americans, to tell the Israelis to stop. It has happening every week since 2004, one of the more remarkable non-violent resistance projects in the world, and yet it remains virtually unmentioned in the American media.

In the background, center, one the Israeli army's omnipresent Sniper Towers overlooks the village and its lands. At right, the insect-like claw of an American-made Caterpillar bulldozer strips the land, ripping an enormous gash along the path of the wall. The child is visibly terrified, and she has every right to be. Israeli Occupation Soldiers have murdered over 700 Palestinian children in the last 1,500 days, and have shot and hospitalized another 13,000 children.

The Palestinians are protesting the illegal confiscation of their land and the construction of a massive prison wall to enclose the village of Imnizel, near Hebron. Nearly 60% of the West Bank is being seized for the exclusive use of Jewish Settlers, for the construction of roads that only Jews can drive on and cities that only Jews can live in. To make sure the land's rightful owners don't cause any distress to the delicate sensibilities of the Jewish extremists who are stealing it, millions of Palestinians are being walled up in hundreds of diconnected prison districts.

ORIGINAL PHOTO: Nayef Haslamoun, Imnizel, Occupied West Bank, July 6, 2005
IMAGE ALTERATION: /anomalous

....

LANGUAGE HAS FAILED ME
by Suheir Hammad


I am told to believe nothing I read
Then everything I read
I am given my own face to be wary of
I am told to fear colors as alerts
I am told over and over
Iraq is not Palestine
Kabul is not New York

The photos
Women Raped
Posed as girls gone wild
This is entertainment This is staged This is
recorded
Men Chained
Do words such as humiliation and torture
Truly fit the immensity of these acts?
What happens to those who survive?
What happens to those responsible?

Haiti is not Chechnya
Chiapas is not East L.A.
Iraq is not Palestine
Over and over I am told

I am given a vantage point and a lens and instructed
Do not move Do not look up Do not look down

I am falling

2.

No connections here
No illuminated parallels
Two different histories and two different peoples
Make no links
Do not confuse the issues

Only confuse the people

For 56 years Israel has legitimized
This type of behavior
Sanctioned violence in the name of a god
Who does not have enough love for us all
A god who chooses sides
A god who has favorites and chosen ones
A god who cuts deals and shuffles souls
The type of god who does not answer prayers
Who understands only one language
A god who does not worry his beautiful mind with
Such ugliness
I am told this is America’s god

The photos from Rafah Palestine
It is 1948 and 2004 in the same frame
Their eyes say to the camera
What will you do with this pain?
Where will you take it?
Can you take it from me?

This space between the lens and the subjects
Is concentrated with pleas for witness
With promises of cycles unbroken
With children’s bicycles under the rubble of once were
homes

Another level of exile is being constructed

And I am falling

Aaagghh, ya Phalesteen
What is it about us they hate so much?
This face? These eyes? This obstinate refusal to
die?
How much trauma can one nation endure with the world
staring?
Some mouths open in shock
Others silent and sneering
While women scream at a frequency the living cannot
hear
Again? Again ya Phalesteen?

3.

How fucked up is it that I have to choose between
ending
One occupation or another?
Partition my time and portion my information

I have to make Nice Play Fair and Polite
When I want to tear open my chest to void it of this
emptiness
This ache has eaten into my head and wears down my
dreams
My friends worry I am not eating enough
Am taking too much on Too much in
I find nowhere to rest this responsibility

If I say nothing I am complicit
If I say something I am isolated as extreme
As a theorist in conspiracy
As if war is ever a coincidence
As if genocide simply happens

This is about oil and land and water
This is about illusion and the taking on of airs
The poor once again the munitions in rich men’s
cannons

This is about light and dark
There is no black and white in humanity

I am told
Venezuela is not Cuba
Rwanda is not Kurdistan

I am not the woman kneeling
In front of soldiers and their cameras and their
weapons
I am not the child shot in the head by the Israeli
Defense Forces
I am not the starving AIDS inflicted mother
Praying I live longer than my children
So they will not be orphaned and sick and have to bury
me
I am not the child who watched
Her family chopped to death in Lebanon in Sudan in
Nicaragua
I am not the father who leaves his children so as not
to hear their
empty Bellies call out Baba, where is the bread?

I am the woman whose taxes outfitted this tragedy
The American the Authority does not speak for
The Arab the Arab leaders do not speak for
The woman whose shouts of Not in My Name
Were spit back at me as a slogan of the misguided at
best
I am the girl from Brooklyn told to mind her business
I am the poet in search of new words
And a new world Not Mars

4.

We use antiquated terms that cannot stretch enough to
touch this truth
We have not learned from the past enough to not repeat
it

I am told it has always been this way
War and Pillage
Rape is older than prostitution
And prostitution is the oldest politic
The way the world has always been
The pimps and those they pimp

The human race has always left
Those who fall behind

If I am to survive then
I learn from the present
From the future promised

We learn to live with madness
One cannot be healthy in a sick world
Only navigate illnesses Only medicate wounds
Pray you are not contagious
Try to hurt no one

My elders say dissent has always been watched
Radical ideas have always been recorded
But even those who have lived on the margins admit
Under breath It has never been this bad

Not everyone is suffering True
Most thirst
A few swim in pools that fake connection to seas
Most starve
I throw away meals I have no appetite for
You can shop from your couch and eat food fast
And never think about anything other than your credit
card debt
And the next hour’s purchases
Shop and stop asking questions
I have envied this stupor
Even knowing it is the least honorable suicide
Even knowing its apathy is another kind of murder

5.

Sometimes all you can do is inhale and exhale
Life a shallow version of its potential
Sometimes all you can do is search for life where you
are
In the city A flash of yellow on the basketball
court
The divine geometry in the pattern of a girl’s hijab

For a week I have been cleaning and knifing enough
Parsley for tabbouleh to feed hundreds
I pray over the green
That what I make will feed those in need of a meal

There is still love in us
The proof is that we are watching it die
There is still hope in us
Hope is there in my sisters’ eyes
There is still enough resistance in us
To create a world where there is no
Your people or my people
But our people
Our people who kill Our people who are killed

I somehow know love will save us
The proof is in the stories not broadcast
The poems not published
The truth between the lies
The stories whispered in the dusk of this day

I know somehow love will save us
Though I can’t find the passion or desire in my body
to make it
There is still a source for peace deeply embedded in
this chaos

I know love will save us
Though words fail to point out how

Amazingly I still pray
To a god I envision to be larger than any nation Any
religion

And I still hunt for language to gather into a poem
That I pray will feed those like me
In need of proof they are not alone

Suheir Hammad
www.suheirhammad.com


....
Here I build my home and here you have destroyed my home
And if this is not legal, what about yours, my cousin?

Ours is a house that was not approved by any of your laws
Our house you will never erase.

-- MC Tamer Nafar



A lot of people these days like to toss around phrases like "Say No To Terror" -- for many such people, saying this is an ironically succint way of expressing their wholehearted support for terrorism - OUR terrorism, at any rate. Please, they are saying, let our terrorism continue, but for gods sake don't make us look at it.

Most of the time, such declarations are intended as a show of strength and solidarity, an attempt to keep fear at bay.

I wonder how many Americans would recognize that this image from Occupied Palestine expresses precisely the same sentiment of defiance in the face of terror?

Say No to terror, indeed.



Please take a moment from your day to play this song loud enough that the neighbors can hear:
www.arna.info/Arna/dam-play.php 

Comments

view profile

byrdiegyrl  Pro User  says:

Very strong image...can still see the fear in that baby's face and posture.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

I wish you could also see the face the soldier is making - his eyes are scary as hell.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

niffer says:

Palestine's people never say goodbye
Suheir Hammad writing from Occupied Jerusalem, Live from Palestine, 26 July 2004

I had a photo (from somewhere) of a soldier pointing his gun at the head of little child, just to amuse himself as the family walked through the checkpoint. The child could not have been older than five and the father looked bewildered. The mother looked like she wanted to tear the soldier apart.

Your work is very inspiring and is giving me a lot of ideas for my own work. Thank you!
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

André Gardenberg  Pro User  says:

strong image!
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

jclutter  Pro User  says:

This alteration is pretty terrifying. I would also like to see the original.

Thank god for the fifth part of this poem... I was ready to stand up in my living room and start yelling to noone that there is hope and good... sometimes in the smallest things.. but it's there.

This part kills me... because it's so true...

"Sanctioned violence in the name of a god
Who does not have enough love for us all
A god who chooses sides
A god who has favorites and chosen ones
A god who cuts deals and shuffles souls
The type of god who does not answer prayers
Who understands only one language
A god who does not worry his beautiful mind with
Such ugliness
I am told this is America’s god."

It hurts me that we don't see how ugly so many of us in this country are making god out to be. People are using their god to support such horrible agendas... such hatred.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

Ultra-right wing Jewish supremacist Tozzo asked, as if it is a matter of serious debate, "who am I to say that these lands seizures are illegal?"

The illegality of these land seizures is established not by me, but by little things like the Geneva Conventions, which governs the conduct of an Occupying Power: "Any destruction by the Occupying Power of real or personal property belonging individually or collectively to private persons, or to the State, or to other public authorities, or to social or co-operative organizations, is prohibited, except where such destruction is rendered absolutely necessary by military operations."

I could add several dozen other treaties and conventions to which Israel is a signatory and legally bound. Among them: the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and The International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, under which israel is obligated "to ... guarantee the right of everyone, without distinction as to race, color, or national or ethnic origin, to equality before the law ... in particular:... the right to housing".

We could also take the decision of the highest court in the entire world, the International Court of Justice in the Hague, whose unanimous denunciation of Israel's wall also clearly affirmed that Israel's home demolition practices were illegal.

Ultimately, the highest manifestation of legality is the informed consensus of the entire world. These practices have been condemned in many hundreds of United Nations resolutions endorsed almost unanimously (with the constant exception of Israel and the US, of course).

People act as if it is a scandalous or tendentious claim to talk about "Illegal" actions in the context of Israel. In fact there has been an unprecedented and unbroken global consensus on these matters for the last 38 years, in which Israel and the US are consistently the only exceptions. It is tragic that most Americans don't even know or care that this is the case.
Posted 54 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

CatsFive  Pro User  says:

We cannot simply blame the government-- literally, it is the political power of the people that creates the aid and turns the blind eye to Israel's attrocities. When I was living in NYC, there was a Jewish guy who once rendered air to several Palestinians during an Israeli raid. I don't remember exactly, but he might have or was rumoured to have rendered ait to Arafat himself, or maybe one of his aides. The man recieved telephone death threats for doing so. The local police initially refused to trace the calls, then, when they were traced, refused to investigate or prosecute. The New York Times got involved and things escalated. I wrote the New York State senator, Schumer, I think, and registered a protest after he himself refused to publicly condemn the death threats. I received a form letter thanking me for my support.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

CatsFive, I agree 10000% with your thoughtful comment. I am not one of these sorts of people who repeat slogans about how its all the governments fault, and if only the government would respond to the will of the people, things would be different.

The Israeli government is telling the people what they want, making them think they desperately need it, and then giving it to them in spades.

The exact same thing is hbeing orchestrated here: a culture of constant anxiety, wrapped around an intense, racist hostility against islam and Arabs, being used to justify a shocking disregard for international law and human rights, and promotion of an ideal of a militarized state engaged in perpetual war against invisible enemies. I would call it the Israeliization of America.

In both cases it is the people who are propelling these policies - American and Israeli people - whose stupid muddied thinking and lazy racist indifference allows this nonsense to continue.

The activist you are referring to was probably Adam Shapiro, one of the original organizers of the ISM. He continues to be hounded by right-wing ZIonists here in America. Many participants in ISM work over there have been attacked by Israelis, deported, beaten, shot, and so far two have been killed - Rachael Corrie and Tom Hurndall.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

Tozzo suggested I should look at "the kingdom of the birds" to understand how it normal and natural that the stong should exterminate the weak.

This is not about birds or natural selection.

It's about deliberate cultural genocide. It's a political problem, not a genetic one.

I have heard the argument made that this is ALWAYS happens, or that if it were Palestininas who were flooding into another continent to kill Jews and steal their country, they would have behaved just as abyssmally. And it is certainly true that countries have invaded and conquered other countries over and over throughout history.

But when you look at the history of colonialism, and at all the various colonial-settler states, it is an inescapable fact that Israel's particular variation on the theme is quite unusual.

Across virtually the entire history of colonialism, the colonizer uses the indigenous population as a captive market and a cheap labor force. There are only a very few examples of colonizers who viewed the very presence of indigenous people as a threat to their existence. While genocide and ethnocide was not an uncommon result of colonization, Israel and the US are among only a handful of countries where it was concluded that the indigenous people could play no part at all in the colonial sociiety - neither as laborers or anything else. They simply had to not be there anymore.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

Tozzo, I am glad you removed your ill-considered justification of genocide. I was in the process of responding with a compare-and-contrast set of virtually identical quotes by Adolf Hitler.

Palestinians are not being crushed today because they are too lazy to want to live. On the contrary, they have mounted a truly historic resistance with virtually nothing against one of the most militarized states in human hisotry.

They are being crushed today because they are massively outgunned, and because they have spent the last 5 generations being deliberately impoverished and de-developed, and because people like yourself - one of the educated middle class Americans who actually pay for their annihilation - would rather spout idle declarations about evolution and survival of the fittest than do or say anything to oppose this injustice.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

For the above post, Tozzo called me a "dangerous ranting fanatic."

Coming from the guy with a Stormtrooper helmet for an icon, who just spammed me about how the genetic inferiority of Palestinians makes it right that they be "eliminated", I take that as a compliment, Tozzo. My only regret is that I didn't save your remarks, so that others could see them.

Might is not right, Tozzo. The strong do not have a divine right or a moral imperative to wipe out the weak.

On the contrary, this is precisely the founding idea of international law and of human rights standards - that those with power have an obligation to safeguard those without power, not to rub them out of existence.

I had added you as a contact because I liekd your photos, but now I notice that you have blocked me from commenting in your page, banned me from the "Just Street Photography" group as punishment, and yet feel free to post repeated abusive comments in my own page.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

Before adding any comment of my own, I'd like to quote Tozzo in full in case he decides to delete his creepy abusive comments again:

Tozzo says: "I have removed all of my comments from your feed for good reason.... The truth is not abusive... as you fanatically point out... Might is right or else there would be no such thing.... I'll say hi to you the next time I look at the bottom of my shoe.... BTW... If you were an Israeli Jew I would say the same thing... I am an equal opportunity truth giver..... this has nothing to do with your images... even the most insane people have gifts.... The stormtrooper is a fictional fantasy character... All of your images deal with hate, not love.... Instead of wasting your time on Websites run by Ali Abunimah and using religion as a tool, you should focus on your images, try and make money off of them, and becoming a better American..... That is why you are in America right? To make money.... or are you here to incite people ....? You were banned because you are more about spewing your hatred and rhetoric than about making good images... Next time you want to say your people are peaceful, remeber this quote from the 6-days-war era: "Our basic objective will be the destruction of Israel. The Arab people want to fight." That's all Arabs like to do... so like the wasp that keeps buzzing near my ear, we will elimiate the pest to restore civilized order...... "

------------

Tozza has a lot of profoundly creepy genocidal crap to say about "my people," even though he doesn't know the first thing about me or my ethnic background. But then facts are irrelevant to racists.

He insists I am a Palestinian, and gleefully explains that he is going to "eliminate pests" like me in the name of civilization.

In fact I am a seventh-generation American from a line of Norwegian imigrants who came here 200 years ago.

I think no further comment is necessary. In a fit of indignation, Roy Carotozzolo now seems to be converting his flickr into an anti-Arab hate site.

Today he posted this:

"In Palestine, there are no amusement parks... for the people are too concerned with hate, guile, and religion... Plus they have devolved into humans that no longer know how to have fun... So the next time one tries to bring you to their side, remind them of how they bomb buses and are the opposite of what Dr. Martin Luther King teaches...."

[In fact there ARE small amusement parks and zoos in Palestine, but I doubt that he would care anyway, because he's too busy explaining that Arabs hate Jews more than they love their own life].

I find it fascinating the way racists are always so eager to seize upon MLK to defend their hatred. I'm sure he would be horrified had he not been murdered. But I can play that card as well: "It is wrong and inhuman to impose the Jews on the Arabs. What is going on in Palestine today cannot be justified by any moral code of conduct."
--Mahatma Gandhi, 1939

In fact the world's largest ongoing example of massive non-violent social struggle has been taking place in the Occupied Territories for the last 2 years in opposition to the wall. Participants - like this man holding a baby in the photo here - are being beaten, killed, arrested, tortured, crippled, and subjected to a variety of chemical weapons. In addition their homes have been bulldozed and family members arrested in retaliation for their peaceful protest.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

Later he posted again - even though he has blocked me from his site and from groups he manages, he can't stop hounding me in my own site -

Tozzo said: "what is creepy is your inability to let go of the land you leave behind and embrace the land you live in.... and what is abusive is your racism towards the people that have done nothing towards you... How come you don't have your name on your feed... what are you afraid of.....? "

It's weird, he's so obsessed with hating me because I'm an Arab that he can't even hear it when I tell him flat out I am not an Arab. I don't have my name on my site precisely because of scary violent obsessives like himself.

He concluded with a link to an ultra-right wing Zionist anti-Arab hate site called "masada2000", operated by an openly-genocial Jewish terrorist group (Kach/JDL) so violently extremist that it is actually BANNED in Israel and most other countries, although allowed to operate with impunity in Brooklyn. The site:
www.masada2000.org/
opens with a quote by the machine-gun toting Brooklyn-born fanatic repsonsible for the 1994 Hebron massacre, Rabbi Mehere Kahane, which left 29 muslim civilians dead in a mosque during prayer, and over 100 wounded.

At this point, I think we will have to block this lovely specimen...
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

Kren [deleted] says:

I was banned from the group by Tozzo, and I just reported him to the flickr administration...
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

If all this is confusing to you, and you don't understand why I am calling Tozzo a racist, I encourage you to look back over what he said about Arabs, and say it about Jews. Then you can hear it more clearly, because we have all, thankfully, been sensitized to anti-semitism.

Let me give you an example, and you tell me if it is racist: "Jews are too concerned with hate, guile, and religion... Plus they have devolved... Destroying and fighting is all Jews like to do... so like the wasp that keeps buzzing near my ear, we will eliminate the Jewish pest to restore civilized order...... "

You will not find such horrifying things said about Jews or ANY group in my photostream. Because unlike Tozzo's vision of a world in which "inferior races" are exterminated by superior ones, I advocate a world in which all human lives are of equal value, where human rights and international law are the standards by which conflicts are decided, rather than blind ethnic rage coupled with superior firepower. Every position I have advocated here is in accordance with the views endorsed by the entire world community in many hundreds of United Nations resolutions concerning Palestine. My impression is that Tozzo, like many Israelis and many Americans, believe that law is irrelevant, and that our superior strength gives us a right to commit any manner of crime against those who refuse to give us everything we want - be it land, or oil, or a perverse vision of ethnic purity in which our "enemies" either leave or simply cease to exist. Or maybe he's just having a REALLY bad day. It certainly is unbearably hot and humid here right now.

Have a look at what he's done next:

flickr.com/groups/topic/68622/

flickr.com/groups/topic/68996/
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Sam Haque  Pro User  says:

Wow, that guy is seriously ill. Thanks for copy pasting for us to see.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

alex craig  Pro User  says:

thanks for your note , sorry you ended up being subjected to all of that & I'm sorry to see that sort of racism on flickr
, stay well
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

Kren [deleted] says:

Unfortunately racists do exist and this nauseating incident at least showed us that your photos are very powerful and they give the appropriate messages.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

I just thought I would add to this archive some of the things Tozzo is now saying about me. Bl;ocking me from commenting in his own flickr and banning me from a street phtoography group was not enough for him. He then had to use his position to send notices to over 500 members of the group explaing that I am a terrorist and encouragign them to contact the FBI about me.

Tozzo wrote, under the header "A Racist user has been banned, as his minions follow":

""AnomalousNYC, a very good street photographer (as decided by certain people) has been banned due to his use of flickr as a way to promote hate. He contends that he is not doing so, but if you look at all of his PRO-Palestinian images on his thread you will see that he lacks the full understanding of why there is a conflict at all... Many people comment on how wonderful his images are, but if you knew the truth behind why he puts them there you would be appalled.... Once confronted with this, lies about myself were conjured up to mask his true intentions... destruction of all that America is (or should) about now... peace.

Do not promote this person... Do not help this person... If you see this person... tell them to go away... He does not tell us his name, nor show his face... he is the definition of coward and if he ever tries to hurt you, me or anyone I know please contact the proper authorities..... I am very close to calling the FBI and reporting him as a terrorist sympathizer...."

....

After several dozen group members announced they were leaving the group because of his wierd behavior, he went through and edited out all their critiques of him and banned some of them.

He wrote:

"A good friend of mine was a minesweeper for the Israeli Military... He died on a mission trying to clear mines for settlers... I disagree with both sides... But I especially disagree with someone who promotes the continued lie that the land must be divided and that the use of bombs and terror is the proper way to that end. So if you are calling me a racist for thinking that, you are just not at any level I would even want to bother with.... Talk to the hand in other words... I was raised to live with all kinds of humans... All of us in the NYC area have. If these people can't do it by now, Arabs and everyone else there, then fuck them... We do not need humans who are separatists any more... All of you who blasted me simply because I blasted AnomalousNYC, you are lame and I would not want you here anyway.....

And the other person I banned, Kren, his images were not that good anyway, so we will not miss that person... plus he is the kind of person that threatens people... I did not do that... so we will dis him with no shame... I dish it out, so I can take it... give me your best Kren... I will be waiting with a smile, some sweat on my brow... and a very good aim.... I will be going away for a few weeks, so please continue to make yourselves look like separatist lovers here in this thread.... Clones are what the stormtroopers were initially in that story I like... fantasy, a wonderful thing... embrace it and have some more coffee.... Get over it... No one cares... AnomalousNYC is a tool and a pawn and has been brainwashed... This has nothing to do with his images... That was never in question... But he can take them somewhere else, as can all that sweat him..... Finally, an just an FYI, THIS IS A RACIST AND A PROPOGANDA WHORE {a clip from your precious AnomalousNYC}: ["The goal is nothing less than the complete eradication of Palestine as a nation, as a culture, as a living presence in the land that Israel is currently stealing for its exclusive use. Israel`s beautiful dream is to reduce a proud and modern nation into a hellish prison camp inhabited by retarded fundamentalists and illiterate cave-dwellers, huddling in rubble, drinking out of pools of raw sewage, begging for scraps of food from Jews."] See what I mean... so lame and tired... Go home and you know what dude... Peace!"

When another discussion thread was strated in which people declared they were leaving the group, he replied:

"stop inciting hate like AnomalousNYC.. leave the group please... this was the whole point don't you see? To purge people like you from here.... anyone who sides with AnomalousNYC thinks Jews and Israel should be destroyed... and that is just wrong..."

He added: "this all started because I was looking at [anomalous'] feed and it had inciting and hateful comments on it... so I shot back at him and he did not like that.... Boo HOO... that is what mouths are for... maybe if more people said what they thought without a filter and stopped being politically correct we would all be in a better state right now.... so go side with the hateful fanatic and continue to misunderstand the topic....

and I am deleting and removing all the crap I see that is wrong.... so don't come on and say "oh tozzo you removed my words..." Yep I sure did...."

Tozzo may be struggling with his own personal kind of madness, but he is also exhibiting another, political, kind of insanity: Zionism. His appears to be garden-variety homegrown american christian zionism, but who knows. It's irrelevant.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

M.kalida [deleted] says:

Well....I still choose to belive that everything can be solved by calm talking and toleranz and understanding for each others.Am I the only idiot that thinks that way in this world??
I do not want to get into politics...I lived in war and I am really sick of hate and killing for no reason.In that matter I also choose to spare my brain and soul cause I have enough for this life. Any killing hurts me, no matter which rase. We are all people.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

jentizzle says:

yay, I've earned myself a ban from the just street photography group (theoretically something anyone should be able to belong to, regardless of their views on Israel-Palestine, no?) as well. But not before I contacted the other administrators and asked them if it was their policy to ban people on the basis of their political beliefs. ONE admin sent me an email back, saying he would take it up with tozzo. This is from eyecatcher

"It is not the policy of the group to ban people based on their political beliefs. However Tozzo has unilaterally exercised his right as an administrator to ban some members.

I think it is not the right thing to do and I will take up the issue with him and the other administrators to try to resolve the problem.

Thank you for your concern."

I've also let the main flickr administration know. Strangely enough, tozzo had me on his contacts list before all of this happened! I'm not sure what's up with him, but I really think he should seek counseling. Having a friend die (re: his friend who was an Israeli army minesweeper) is always terrible and traumatic, but that's certainly no reason to decide to hate every person of Palestinian origin...how very, very misguided.

Oh, and with regard to the photo, great image manipulation. I wonder if the soldier is just following orders, or really believes in what he is doing (disrupting a peaceful protest and threatening an unarmed man with a child). Scary.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

Thanks for your comments Jen! It is wierd that any of this was even brought to that group in the first place - because I certainly never posted anything there about Israel/Palestine. Even wierder is this strange retroactive editing - where he goes back and alters or erases his comments and deletes other people's comments.

For some reason it especially creeps me out that he keeps insisting I am an Arab regardless of the fact that I am not. I have to say I think the guy is seriously unhinged.

...

as for the photo above, I don't think it's so much a matter of this soldier "believing in" anything at all. This kind of behavior is generated almost automatically by the kind of culture that prevails in the Israeli military, and by the general dynamics of the situation. It's a combination of intense boredom, anger, ambient cultural racism, and pragmatism that produces this kind of conduct. It's revolting behavior, but often they're just doing what they think will get the job done the most smoothly based on their (racist) understanding of the situation. They have a job to do and the desires and interests and welfare of the "cancer" - as the Israel Minister of Defense calls the Palestinians - are irrelevant.

This is really the main "flavor" of Israeli racism: it's NOT like a Jewish version of the KKK, with people sitting around plotting night and day how to kill Arabs. When people say that "Zionism is racism" - as most of the world's countries have said at the United Nations - they are not referring to THAT kind of racism.

It's more of a situation in which Jewish needs and anxieties and safety are seen as SO extremely, overhwelmingly important, that everything else simply becomes irrelevant. One can easily understand how such a mindset could arise - not that this forgives anythign or makes it any less racist.

Zionists tell themselves that it is necessary that Jews must be able to sit without nervousness at cafe tables in Israel, and from there they leap single-mindedly to the conclusion that it's "ok" that an entire ethnic group shoul dbe violently subjugated and millions of Palestinians should be locked up for the rest of their lives in maximum security prisons. Hey, whatever it takes for Jews to feel safe, right? The rights of those innocent people are simply not relevant to them, because foremost in their mind are Jews, what Jews need and what Jews want. That Palestininas might ALSO like to be able to sit in cafes is not worthy of discussion. Every little threat to their complete and absolute security and comfort is inflated into an existential threat, a "second holocaust." Meanwhile, what Palestinians might need or want, or that they might have any wants or needs at all, is simply never considered.

When Palestinians INSIST on their needs, it is simply interpreted by many Zionists as hating Jews, aggression against jews, denying Jews their rights, trying to destroy Israel. Even as the many JEWISH critics of Israel and advocates of Palestinian rights are demonized as "self-hating Jews."

I posted a short account of one Israeli soldier here, at the following link. He wrote a scandalous booklet called "Checkpoint Syndrome", parts of which I transcribed here. You might find it interesting. It is certainly a very powerful look at how these kinds of situations crush those immersed in them, regardless of whether they are the ones with the guns or the ones being shot at.

www.flickr.com/photos/anomalous/27810120/in/s et-522872/


"How wrong does Israel have to be before you speak up?"
--Shulamit Aloni, former member of the Israeli Knesset
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

My latest Zionist stalker sethfrantzman said: "Actually the soldier is yelling at a Jewish settler who is being evicted from his home."

Actually, he's NOT. But then reality has never been a big concern for racists.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

CatsFive  Pro User  says:

How interesting that, once you fuzz away enough of the detail, the Palestinian in that picture could, in Tozzo's mind, be a settler being evicted from his home.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

I sincerely doubt he thinks that. He is just doing what Zionists do - which is to lie and lie and lie in order to deliberately contrive controversy where in fact there is no controversy at all.
Posted 52 months ago. ( permalink )

matkaantytto [deleted] says:

Wonderful, I love all your streams! God bless PALESTINE!!!! My mother, an American, is very, very, VERY much against Israel. Which then all Jews thinks she anti-Semetic and anti-Israel. (rolls eyes).
Posted 34 months ago. ( permalink )

matkaantytto [deleted] says:

Americans, now know I sent it to a ridiculous amount of ppl
Posted 34 months ago. ( permalink )

armedchicksrule [deleted] says:

Execute the palestinian terrorist and the terrorist in training too!
Posted 27 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

samson78  Pro User  says:

What a contraversial photo.. This is one person, behaving in a way which is very provocative. Nobody knows what transpired in order to get this man and this soldier arguing. These are both two people having a disagreement. I think that things like this tend to drive people away from one another and are definitely counterproductive to human rights in general. No matter what happened or what the intent was on the part of either the man or the soldier.
Posted 27 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

Whats controversial here? The man is holding a baby and standing on his own land, in his own country. The soldier - from another country - has NO RIGHT TO BE THERE.

And what is the solder doing? Well we know because of the Associated Press photographer who was there. He was trying to stop a legal, non-violent protest. And what was the protest about? The villagers were trying to stop the soldiers from demolishing part of their village and lands in order to build an ILLEGAL, 30 foot high wall through their property.

You say nobody knows what transpired, but it is perfectly clear. The details you are worrying about - who said what, or what trivia occurred - are irrelevant. The soldier has no right to be there. The soldiers have no right to try to prevent peaceful assembly by these people on their own lands. The wall itself is illegal. So this is not simply a "disagreement" - it is a crime taking place, and in this instance, one side is perfectly in the right, and the other absolutely in the wrong.

This is nothing controversial at all. The people are doing what they are supposed to do - which is stand up for their rights - and the soldier is doing what Israeli soldiers do, which is humiliating and dominating Arabs, denying their basic rights, and stealing their land.. He is, at best, "just following orders" and at worst, a true believer. Either way, he is engaged in the crime of ethnic cleansing - forcing non-Jews off their own land to make way for Jews. His intent is irrelevant, as is your twaddle about how drawing attention to this crime - yes, its a crime - is "counterproductive to human rights."
Posted 27 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

wavetowake says:

Wow, amazing shot. creditorlink.com/credit-card-articles/credit- cards-for-pe...
Posted 27 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

George Augustine says:

Good picture..It has a plastic quality about it..like the subjects are all toys..
Posted 27 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

George Augustine says:

Good picture..It has a plastic quality about it..like the subjects are all toys..and unreal
Posted 27 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Hotpixel69 says:

fukin jews...they don't have any rights on that land...
Posted 27 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

chimchimari says:

all this hatress and murder just because of land!! I dont get it! just listen to bob marley songs! What is it for they have to die?? where does this hatress come from??? we all have just ONE life on earth...ok buddhits have more...but anyways! PEACE!!!
Posted 26 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

land= life

Because the Israelis deny Palestinians a state, and any rights, or human rights, or legal rights, or moral rights, or property rights, Israel can kill Palestinians by the thousands, year after year, for decades. If it can't quite get away with slaughtering them outright, it can at least starve them to death, which it's trying to do now.

There will be peace when Israelis are prepared to grant Palestinians the same rights they demand for themselves - right to land, to a state, to security and self-defense, to live in peace.

Peace is impossible now because of Zionism, and only because of zionism.

4 out of 5 Israelis advocate nuking Iran. 9 out of ten advocate walling up Palestinians in ethnic prisons for the rest of their lives. This sickness is called ZIONISM. The Israeli state has become a sickness, and there will be no peace as long as the sickness - zionism - is allowed to gangrenize the entire region.

Let me clarify that the disease here is not JEWS or Israelis, but simply an IDEA - a hateful and genocidal racist ideology called zionism. Change the idea and peace is quite easy to see - a peace in which jews and muslims and christians live again in peace in Palestine, as they have for centuries before the coming of zionism.

If people are allowed to speak freely and tell the truth about what Israel is doing, this sickness will evaporate. If zionists continue to terrorize the world into silence, the rot of zionism's genocidal anti-muslim hatred will devour the planet.

Peace is so easy - just a change of mind away.










.
Posted 26 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

≡(εїз๑ ℓõşŤ ŜØůζ ๑εїз)≡ says:

= (
Posted 26 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

PuchongFlickrer98 says:

makes me cry reading your description.
Posted 25 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

youssuf_sharifi says:

very powerful. stay steadfast.
Posted 25 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

aburashdan says:

send that TOJO guy to me, i have no taste for jewry for if need be i can swallow a bunch of brooklyn strands and wash them down the drain. i will need non-kosher grapes from palestine though. TOJO, you don't need to call your uncle sam next time you see me, you will know me by my name and my looks, i wont have even a pencil cutter in my hand, but i know litttle eikes like you talk big and piss a lot.
Posted 25 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Stilista says:

This is hearbreaking!
You are very well spoken and obviously very well educated.
I am so sorry that you were subjected to all the hate that this beautiful piece of work brought you...but then again, you were standing up for something you believe in and Tozzo's words were nothing compared to what others in their countries are dealing with.
Stay strong and stay true!!
Love.....
Posted 25 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

living asleep  Pro User  says:

got the unaltered version ? i bet its nice and raw
good shot
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

"""ADRIAN says:

Baruch atah Adonai Eloheinu Melech ha'o'lam sheh'heh'cheh'ya'nu veh'ki'yeh'ma'nu veh'he'g'a'nu laz'man ha'zeh.
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

yet more words that have failed us.
Posted 23 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

hortulus says:

Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Men together, and we'd love to have your photo added to the group.
Posted 22 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Michelle E. Newton-Carline says:

FFP Award
You are my favorite,please add this great 5+ fav photo to
Flickr Favorite Photographers(5+ fav/comment 3/invite 2)
Posted 21 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

byderiN says:

son of a beach israel soldier
Posted 21 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

aerialsilentsun says:

Zionis soldier..... *_*
How odd that there's no other muslim country help Palestine,
Where're they?
HAMAS is the real mujahid who defend their land.
As a moslem I feel sad for not Jihad there...
When all moslem unite in one khalifah then who againts Islam will scary.
Another Israel Conspiracy in Palestine
Watch this..
www.flickr.com/photos/aerialsky/2397660122/
Posted 20 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Muslimah99 says:

indeed, a strong image
Posted 19 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

fimoman says:

You think "language has failed us" and yet i've never seen such long descriptions and comments on flickr. Yours are the longest.
Posted 19 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

lol

yeah, thats the thing about zionists - its why no one ever talks about it and its why they always get what they want.

what's going on is really quite simple, but no one seems to notice. because they're always on the attack, always smearing adn threatening anyone who says anything, always surrounding everything they do with lies and the most outrageous fictions, so that no one knows what the fuck is going on and what is true and false, and are constantly attacked for asking, and eventually give up trying to understand. It's a virulent kind of ideological terrorism.

It's almost unique in the world this way. If I were to take up any other cause here, to try to raise sympathy for any other suffering group of people, everything would be different.

I wouldn't have to be a walking encyclopedia on this subject.

I wouldn't have to spend 20 years studying this crap in the most minute detail imaginable.

I wouldn't be hospitalized from attacks by Israeli stalkers, or have these fuckers trying to get me fired from my job or trying to have me banned from flickr.

I wouldn't have to write 30 paragraph-long essays to "explain" why the victims deserve your help and why the victimizers needs to be stopped, because it would be OBVIOUS.

All of this would be different, because for everything else it is NORMAL to have concern for the victims of oppression. It is considered decent and human to resist racism and violent subjugation.

But in this everything is turned on its head because of the relentless work of zionists to demonize Palestinans, arabs, and islam, and to viciously attack in the most brutal and shocking ways anyone who challenges their ridiculous fables.

It's worked for them so far, so they just keep at it. A good share of the million dollars-an-hour US taxpayers shovel to Israel goes to this incredible PR project to conceal Israel's outrageous crimes behind layer after layer of bullshit.
Posted 19 months ago. ( permalink )

*~Abby Road~* [deleted] says:

that's not right
Posted 19 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

»ĐóήŢ pŁάҮ ŴİŢĦ Mė« says:

orly? Can YOU say why its not right ?? .. i don't think so. [ Not every thing you hear from your daddy is right ].
Posted 18 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

super*dd  Pro User  says:

it's so sad to lost your land.
Posted 16 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Andreas who has left [deleted] says:

Hi, I'm an admin for a group called All People Are Equal, and we'd love to have this added to the group!
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

art makes me smile  Pro User  says:

Language and reason has failed us I agree...
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

fellinisimo says:

helal olsun sana
Posted 13 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

newman_asaso says:

Israel is a Nazi
Israel is a Nazi
Israel is a Nazi
Posted 13 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

mirzahanmirzo says:

Dishonourable israil
Posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

mirzahanmirzo says:

Dishonourable israil !!
Posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

Hotpixel69 says:

you can not ask much of a terrorist government like Israel...
Posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )

view profile

AnomalousNYC  Pro User  says:

We can and must ask the same of Israel as we should of any other government, terrorist or otherwise:

comply with international law in a meaningful and comprehensive way, and strictly observe human rights laws, or suffer very grave consequences.

Unfortunately the complete impunity Israel enjoys for its appalling naziesque performance is merely a subset of the larger problem of US criminal impunity.
Posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

[?]
view photos Uploaded on July 8, 2005
by AnomalousNYC

AnomalousNYC's photostream

1,897
uploads

This photo also belongs to:

Palestine Project (Set)

244
items

Palestine (Pool)

Posters U Make (Pool)

War: memories, fears, nightmares, ghosts. (Pool)

Protests and Demonstrations (Pool)

Construction Zone (Pool)

Protests, Political Art, Democracy, Social Change (Pool)

FORSAKEN BY SOCIETY (Pool)

War (Pool)

AntiWar: Pictures that Protest the Madness. (Pool)

Free Palestine (Pool)

People who make a better world (Pool)

All People Are Equal (Pool)

Tags

Additional Information

All rights reserved Anyone can see this photo

Add to your map
Anyone will be able to see this on the map
 (edit)