Roberts 6 and 7 and SASOL 3rd Edition gives
the "new" name as Orange-breasted
Waxbill. Interesting thing is that SASOL and
Roberts PDA list next to the image that the
scientific name of this bird is Amandava subflava while the text in Roberts PDA list the
scientific name as Sporaeginthus subflavus like you recorded it.
Thanks Francois; I have always known this
bird as the Orange-breasted Waxbill (or
Rooi-asie), but I have used the Clements (ed
5) names here, because that is the authority
used by the "Field Guide: Birds of the
World" group. Avibase ( www.bsc-eoc.org/avibase/avibase.jsp?lang=EN&
pg=home ) is a great on-line resource for sorting
out different names, as well as lumps and
splits.
Just for interest sake so replies I got from
SA Birdnet.
Matthew Grainger; Zoology Dept Univ Pretoria says
Just had a quick look at Cities and they use
the name Amandava subflava, but note two alternatives Sporaeginthus subflavus and Estrilda subflava. From what little information I can gather
it seems there is some taxonmic dispute
regarding this species and therefore the two
names are currently in use by different
authorities and bird book publishers. I will
try and dig in a bit further, hopefully
someone else might know the full details of
the dispute.
As to its common name, "Zebra
Waxbill" is the name they are sold as in
the pet trade.
Ian Hinze from Natural World says:
Taxonomy can be a real pain. The
Orange-breasted Waxbill, a.k.a..Goldbreast
and Zebra Waxbill was originally known
scientifically as Fringilla subflava, then Sporaeginthus subflavus, then Amandava subflava and now Sporaeginthus subflavus again. However, some taxonomists still
prefer to call it Amandava subflava due to its having similarities to the two
Asian avadavats. Nevertheless, there are also differences
which make the bird better placed in Sporaeginthus.
Which is right? That depends on which YOU
prefer. There is no universal agreement as to
its scientific name nor even to its English
name, although some standardisation as to the
latter has been called upon (see Birds of the
world - recommended English names by Frank
Gill & Minturn Wright and published on
behalf of the International Ornithological
Congress. Using this publication
Orange-breasted Waxbill is the preferred
English name).
I've two males of them here in my aviary. No
female for them, here in Italy nobody sells
those birds no more. Damn! My guys: Good shot Alan! Beautiful wild subject!
keyboard shortcuts:
← previous photo
→ next photo
L view in light box
F favorite
< scroll film strip left
> scroll film strip right
? show all shortcuts
Comments and faves
eulaewing added this photo to their favorites. (48 months ago)
CharlesLam (48 months ago | reply)
Beautiful bird, great shot.
Francois Dreyer (48 months ago | reply)
Good photo. Still need to see this one.
Roberts 6 and 7 and SASOL 3rd Edition gives the "new" name as Orange-breasted Waxbill. Interesting thing is that SASOL and Roberts PDA list next to the image that the scientific name of this bird is Amandava subflava while the text in Roberts PDA list the scientific name as Sporaeginthus subflavus like you recorded it.
Alan Manson (48 months ago | reply)
Thanks Francois; I have always known this bird as the Orange-breasted Waxbill (or Rooi-asie), but I have used the Clements (ed 5) names here, because that is the authority used by the "Field Guide: Birds of the World" group. Avibase ( www.bsc-eoc.org/avibase/avibase.jsp?lang=EN& pg=home ) is a great on-line resource for sorting out different names, as well as lumps and splits.
Francois Dreyer (48 months ago | reply)
Just for interest sake so replies I got from SA Birdnet.
Matthew Grainger; Zoology Dept Univ Pretoria says
Ian Hinze from Natural World says:
Dario Corea (48 months ago | reply)
I've two males of them here in my aviary. No female for them, here in Italy nobody sells those birds no more. Damn!

My guys:
Good shot Alan! Beautiful wild subject!
Keith@Worldbirds.eu (47 months ago | reply)
Hi, I'm an admin for a group called The Friends Of Worldbirds, and we'd love to have this added to the group!
MDH11 and Keith@Worldbirds.eu added this photo to their favorites.