Strobist.com / Discuss

Current Discussion

STICKY  Strobist FAQ
Latest: 2 months ago
C-stand / Boom fully extended, maximum angle
Latest: 17 minutes ago
OT kinda Photo sharing site with good FB integration ?
Latest: 20 minutes ago
Radio Popper w/ Non Hot Shoe Flashes
Latest: 53 minutes ago
OT: converting monopod to light stick
Latest: 65 minutes ago
3 light + reflector portrait set up advice
Latest: 2 hours ago
What kind of bracket are these pros using? Are they effective as off-camera?
Latest: 4 hours ago
Slightly OT or looking for Zebras
Latest: 5 hours ago
Phottix Strato II with other cameras
Latest: 5 hours ago
OT: Which Lightroom 3.3 or 4?
Latest: 6 hours ago
Which Yongnuo?
Latest: 7 hours ago
Mimicking an Incandescent Bulb with Flash
Latest: 8 hours ago
More...

Search this group's discussions

Old masters we can learn from?

view profile

James Rubio says:

Caravaggio, Rembrandt, El Greco... amazing masters of light... I need more! The problem is that I am not very knowledgeable of the art world.

Help me out... what other great artists are there? They don't have to be old... just great light and composition.
Posted at 8:33PM, 26 November 2007 PDT (permalink)

view photostream

oaxoax  Pro User  says:

Those are all good ... here's a Rembrandt. Look at the use of light and shadow.

The Dutch Master
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

flashgordo says:

Here is a link. Tons of masters. Sometimes I clip poses for reference.

www.abcgallery.com/

That piece above is great. And notice the light is OFF camera ( I mean off canvas, or off artist... well, you know)
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
flashgordo edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

James Rubio says:

Rembrandt got it down.

Thanks for the link -- wow, lots of inspiration there... Keep them coming!!
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

strobist is a group administrator strobist  Pro User  says:

You mean, besides Wizwow?

(hehheh)
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

carlos.benjamin is a group moderator carlos.benjamin says:

Boy, he'll be hot about that one........ as soon as he wakes up from his nap........
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

IllOgical42 says:

Keep'm coming? flashgordo didn't provide enough information, or have you already absorbed that whole website?!? ;)

I'd say visit a musuem and talk to the people who work/visit. Seeing such an object of beauty on a computer screen does not compare to seeing the real thing (or reproduction ;) ).
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

strobist is a group administrator strobist  Pro User  says:

CB-

Yeah, now that he has figured out how to increase the font size in his browser, he catches a lot more stuff...

I understand he did a workshop with Vermeer once. That's where he learned how to do kiarascur... charakura... uh, crosslighting.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

lauriemarie01  Pro User  says:

Actually, If you look really close at the mirror detail in Jan van Eyck's Arnolfini Wedding, I think you can see Wizwow. I think there's even a strobe reflection. Is he using on-camera flash with a small softbox for a little fill?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Arnolfini_Portrait

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:The_Arnolfini_Portrait,_d%c3%...
(Sorry, Wizwow. I couldn't resist.)
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
lauriemarie01 edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

strobist is a group administrator strobist  Pro User  says:

You know, you're right. Just didn't recognize the dark hair!
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Don Giannatti (aka wizwow) says:

"Dark hair" yeah yeah... funny...
Lets' all make fun of the geriatric guy.
As soon as the Metamucil kicks in and I can get to my walker I'll have a thing or two to say about....

what were we talking about?

I didn't use strobes here. We set fire to a couple of villagers that were accused of heresy and placed them in front of shiny mirrors. The bounced light provided a very soft, yet warm feeling. I hung silk stolen from some Bedouins in between. That diffused the light.

My fourteen assistants (all nubile young women) made quick sketches of their assigned portions. (sort of like a polaroid, but so much more fun to watch...) I then painted with light.... brushes.

Heh...

Thanks Carlos for the headsup....
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
Don Giannatti (aka wizwow) edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

timmui  Pro User  says:

LMAO. Can't breathe.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Airchinapilot  Pro User  says:

I really like Vermeer. That is the painterly style that I want to achieve.
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
Airchinapilot edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

ardilationship says:

i was about to mention vermeer he is great treating light
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

strobist is a group administrator strobist  Pro User  says:

Wiz-

I knew you'd come through.

ardilationship-

Vermeer used Profoto, from what I understand. 7B's.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

visualdensity  Pro User  says:

Geez... someone just explained how Rembrant used SB-24 and SB-26 to light his Philosopher Meditating. That guy needs help ;) ... wonder who he is... ??
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

NabityPhotos  Pro User  says:

Blasphemy.... all blasphemy.

Although I did reverse engineer daVinci's Last Supper and noticed how he gobo'd his Vivitarius CCLXXXV to leave the background windows darkened...it balances well with the exterior ambient light.

lastsupper

Now we're all gonna go where the color temperature is 2100*.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Light Snaffler  Pro User  says:

Check out this pic I shot. I think that this is what you guys are talking about. I shot this picture over the weekend for my Christmas card. Rembrandt was my inspiration, along with some Vermeer. I did study painting in another life. But cameras are oh so much faster.




Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Benitofoto says:

I'm just curious.... how old do you have to be in order to be considered an OLD Master?

Whatever age it is, I don't think I'm there yet.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

lauriemarie01  Pro User  says:

Nabity, It looks like DaVinci was using a 2 stop grad ND in addition to balancing his strobes to the ambient. I think that was a bad call on his part.

(Actually, the image doesn't look quite right. There should be a lot more detail in the ceiling.)

Wiz...You're a good sport!
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
lauriemarie01 edited this topic 55 months ago.

The Good Reverend Ogalthorpe [deleted] says:

In order to be an old master, one must first be considered to be a master.

-Confucius
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
The Good Reverend Ogalthorpe edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

labrossephotography  Pro User  says:

Desiree Dolron has some serious "Dutch master" style light going on in her photography. The work is truly stunning.

- - - - - - warning - - - - - some photos at the link below may be NSFW so only click on the link if you are at home.

Enjoy!

www.desireedolron.com/
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
labrossephotography edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

A.J. French says:

here is one I like (large softbox to the painter's left - and maybe a snooted flash on the plant in the foreground? ;-)
"Dalliance" by Miklós Barabás
the guy is actually trying to turn off the lady's ipod
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Mikko Reinikainen  Pro User  says:

A.J., that painting reminds me of a nice thread about studying the light of masters we had six months ago.
Don't miss the 17th century "Dave Hill look". Sorry, Ogalthorpe.
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
Mikko Reinikainen edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

flippantfiasco  Pro User  says:

Vermeer painted with a Camera Obscura and was obsessed with tiny details. In that sense, he's the closest to a photographer. The only thing is, he painted almost exclusively in his studio and always scenes lit from the left by a window (which remains to this day a great way to light people and things).

The Baroque period would probably be the best if you're looking for light as an integral property of a composition. The Renaissance paintings are fairly flat-looking in comparison; the Rococo period that loosely speaking followed the Baroque is often "lit" very softly and discretely in comparison to the drama of (in particular) the Catholic baroque artists (which is to say, not including Rembrandt, basically).

Velasquez modified Caravaggio's "tenebrism" (or extreme, directional light-shadow transitions) much in the same way as the early Rembrandt works.


Las Meninas, by Velasquez
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

schmiedl-images  Pro User  says:


Another Vermeer :)
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
schmiedl-images edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

matthew goldsbrough says:

I'd love to recreate "An Experiment on a Bird in the Air Pump" (1768) by Joseph Wright of Derby. The painting is stunning. It's in the National Gallery in London.


Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

tby_v says:

Neil Turner over at

www.dg28.com

has a technique page on north light photography

www.dg28.com/technique/north_light.htm

Check his site out all over but that page is pertinent to this discussion

tby_v
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Jon_Senior says:

@lauriemarie01: The painting is quite clearly a composite of two images. And by looks of things, in the left hand image, Da Vinci had got his shutter speed too high for his eBay triggers.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

savannahmd says:

Old Masters? It all looks like Photoshop trickery to me. :)
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

tmamer says:

Caravaggio really is the Original. especially when you look at single light source.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

maneeacc  Pro User  says:

... i did a last supper remake... well... tried to...

www.flickr.com/photos/maneeacc/317598652/

www.flickr.com/photos/maneeacc/317598891/

but yes... old paintings are quite the light study... even for postures and subject positions... 500 years old... but works like a charm... inspirational...
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Johnny Kurtz  Pro User  says:

This is my first post to this group, just want to say hello and I really appreciate the insight I glean from Strobist.

Well, Vermeer of course comes to my mind first, but I have always loved his works.

I was walking through the main Boston Public Library last year, in a closed off section (sneaky me), and came accross this ladder that screamed Vermeer. Later when I got home, I went through a book of Vermeer's works and decided it was his "Milkmaid" painting that this ladder remind me of; I am glad I photographed it.

Vermeer's Ladder

Check out this link for some great works www.umehon.maine.edu/civilizations/211/dutchgenre-b.htm

Cheers,
Johnny
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
Johnny Kurtz edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

www.johnowenphotography.co.uk  Pro User  says:

I viewed a Rubin show in Brussels at the weekend and looked at them in a different way since getting more into photography

Portraits looked like he used a lot of single point light to cast a shadow on one side of the face
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

SouthsideDuc says:

Painting hard light is hard to do and impressive when it is done well. Don't limit yourself to the dead guys, though. Current painters are also doing incredible work. Check out Arsen Kurbanov, for example.

www.millergallery.com/title.php?ititlenum=10005137

Don't forget about the masters of painting soft diffused light. Monet's Haystacks are something that comes immediately. But if you're thinking about portraits Bouguereau is someone to look at.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:William-Adolphe_Bouguereau_(1...
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Thiago Sanna F. Silva says:

Funny to see this thread coming up. I actually just bought "Art History for Dummies" (don't laugh, the dummy books are usually great, if you just get past the title), and I was coming up with this project for myself, to try to emulate the styles and concepts of the different periods and movements, as a learning exercise.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

JPCimage [deleted] says:

How many Stops does oil paint have ?


One thing many of these "old masters" understood very well was "Motivation" in lighting... or shadow. Amazing, they knew to paint boke.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

chimphappyhour  Pro User  says:

I work for an art museum, we have Caravaggio's St John the Baptist. Very heavy use of gridded light. I don't usually hang out in that part of the complex, but now it looks like I need to go for a walk during lunch. :)
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

A.J. French says:

@jpcimage
How many Stops does oil paint have?
hahaha! ;-) nice one
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Wink of an Eye Digital Media  Pro User  says:

Great Stuff on this board

Do any of you know how "ingrained" photographers are with the way the Masters produced depth in their photos.
Why?
Nuture Vs nature.

"We see with our inner eye what we have been taught to see"

What is fimilar is copied or revered



It is our Western Civ influence

Ok....now this segways into the "History of the World Part I"

Then the Critic was born!

www.jdmfilmreviews.com/userimages/user-7121660_1164677975...
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Wink of an Eye Digital Media  Pro User  says:

And one other thing!!!!
photographers didn't have no paint to show shadows and light.

We have to be there when it happens and gobo our shadows and fill our compsition like the chimps we are!.

None of the Master stuff mix'in paint and painting upside down in the cold of some chapel with very big ceilings imitating pictures way before....ahh I'll stop now
;-)
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

andyptak says:

I'd vote for Edward Hopper. His use of more than one apparent light source from different directions is amazing.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Frequent Flasher says:

I'll add my vote for Vermeer. Long before ever seeing the word Strobist or having a clue about anything other than nuking them with on camera flash the lighting in the works by Vermeer really struck me. To tell the truth I hadn't ever thought much about lighting before that. When I saw the movie Girl with a Pearl Earring, a fictional account of the model in the painting by Vermeer of the same name, I was struck that the lighting throughout the movie was inspired by Vermeer. I had never reflected much on movie lighting before either.
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
Frequent Flasher edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

WB - CMH  Pro User  says:

Rembrandt - Parable of the Rich Man.

Speedlight at 1/8 power cupped behind the hand. Rembrandt later reshot the image with the speedlight in the rich man's mouth.
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
WB - CMH edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

O Casasola says:

@eric.schmiedl That is a photo of Queen Elizabeth by Annie Leibovitz
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Marsh Rabbit says:

Just messing around:
RembrandtPlein

DSC_0869crop
Originally posted 55 months ago. (permalink)
Marsh Rabbit edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

Felix SF says:

More about Vermeer again, and the movie "Girl with a pearl earring"
(about the movie, about the painting).

Worth watching, really. (the movie and the painting ;--)
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

~{jon}~ says:

I was inspired by you guys again but never got the chance to try it at home since most of my windows are blocked by trees.

Almost a snap shot since the wedding photog was on his way to do his thing, but I was still able to get this shot after hurriedly setting up my flashes.


Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

F_H_R says:

Can we really learn from old masters ?

I mean, they're dead now... they don't sell any DVD !

Seems a great pic, jon, btw.
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Benny Vision says:

I think the old masters have a DVD in the Akashic records.
They probly did'nt think about light as hard as we strobists, they just saw the pictures in there minds much better and each picture had more feeling and emotion backing it up i bet.
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

solodogs  Pro User  says:

Seeing one of these painters works in person is a truly amazing experience. A photo does not begin to convey the depth of the original. I have seen a Vermeer in the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna cache.virtualtourist.com/2991350-Vermeer-Vienna.jpg and a Rembrandt in the Timken Museum in San Diego www.rembrandtpainting.net/complete_catalogue/storia_b/ima... and they are truly mind boggling.
Speaking of old masters watch the movie " Girl With A Pearl Earring" if you want to see a masterful bit of cinema lighting and cinematography. It was nominated for Academy awards in cinematography, art direction and costume design. It should have won if it didn't.
Originally posted 54 months ago. (permalink)
solodogs edited this topic 54 months ago.

view photostream

eduardo_frances says:

With the recent film noir lighting assignment I would suggest reading this article:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiaroscuro

Baroque painting has dramatic lighting too :) Here Caravaggio, Michelangelo, the Carraci brothers, Rembrandt, Jan Vermeer, Nicolas Poussin, Diego Velásquez, Antoine Le Nain to name a few.

Also here is a great page that has lots of galleries by author www.wga.hu/frames-e.html?/art/index.html
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Darien Chin  Pro User  says:

I've always been a fan of Mucha...

I also like Escher. Neither are probably considered 'old masters' but both were extremely talented artists that have inspired me.
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Brandon D. says:

"Quarter CTO. I like warmth on the key, but not too much. A lot of what you see in my work is color shifts due to time. The inkjet guy said archival. Bullshit. I started getting shifts after just 175 years. Boy, I miss Kodachrome." - Rembrandt

strobist.blogspot.com/2008/12/beers-with-rembrandt.html
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

eduardo_frances says:

@Darien chin: even if this is 12 months old, Mucha ROCKS, I have the bad habit of getting posters because I simply can't control myself from buying them :(.

For those who want to see Mucha's work images.google.com/images?q=alfons mucha&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a&um=1&sa=N&tab=wi
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

tomnorth [deleted] says:

Monet and Renoir.
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Steve.Korn  Pro User  says:

I didn't use strobes here. We set fire to a couple of villagers that were accused of heresy and placed them in front of shiny mirrors.

Heh, heh, heh...
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

rlketcham says:

I was always a fan of Chuck Close.......
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

timpweb  Pro User  says:

minor white and maplethorpe.
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

David Sr. - says:

This thread is not "25 and under" approved.
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

fstops and shutter speeds [deleted] says:

Maplethorpe? surely you jest...


//bullwhip


there's a great bit in the new Leibovitz book talking about covering conflict in Sarajevo and mentioned how the light usually only came in from one window or door(a result of no electricity...anywhere.) She mentioned it as being deeply moving and most liekyl owing to Rembrandt
Originally posted 42 months ago. (permalink)
fstops and shutter speeds edited this topic 42 months ago.

view photostream

Bo Eder says:

You mean the masters at Playboy don't count?
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Roger Blackwell says:

Studying the old masters is one thing but to create something that will last means more than just copying and continuing a tradition. We have a lot more means at our disposal these days than they did to create interesting images it just means stepping aside somewhat from the current Flickr fashions and doing something that has a personal meaning, IMO.
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

rockhoppermedia says:

Composition is key to this lighting, as points of light are used to direct the viewers attention, however use of different compostion techniques enables the logical response to the lighting.

And in English dont forget compostion principles whilst figuring out your light.
Posted 42 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

DJ D-QUE says:

WOW! Im new to photography and new to learning how to study the art to improve my game. This convo has really put me 5 - 10 years ahead of my peers who have yet to learn or try to learn how to study.
Posted 36 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Scheimpflug Rules says:

I might be old, but at least I don't have Alzheimer's.
Posted 36 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Scheimpflug Rules says:

I might be old, but at least I don't have Alzheimers.
Posted 36 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

ChrisVPhoto says:

Well, with that double post, I'm not sure you remembered you hit "Post Now" already :P
Posted 36 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Darien Chin  Pro User  says:

maybe you do
Posted 36 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Darien Chin  Pro User  says:

maybe you do
Posted 36 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Steve.Korn  Pro User  says:

Keep it down in here, Wizwow's trying to sleep!
Posted 36 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

dialac1 says:

LMAO...OMG, YOU ARE CRAZY...Now my ribs hurt from laughing
Posted 36 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

david.capino says:

did you guys already see this theory that Carvaggio actually may have used... photography onto his canvas to make his compositions? i thought it was interesting and kind of funny if it turned out to be true. www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/art/4968509/Caravaggio-used-p...
Posted 24 months ago. (permalink)

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

RSS 2.0 feedSubscribe to a feed of stuff on this page...</!!> Feed – Subscribe to Strobist.com discussion threads