EOS Cameras and Manual Lenses / Discuss

Current Discussion

STICKY  The adapter Topic
Latest: 3 days ago
STICKY  Introduce yourself here and welcome
Latest: 10 days ago
STICKY  Useful links for manual lens users
Latest: 3 months ago
STICKY  Comprehensive List of Lens Reviews
Latest: 5 months ago
What have they done to Flickr?
Latest: 75 minutes ago
Mirror Mod to 5d Mark 1
Latest: 16 hours ago
hasselblad and EOS
Latest: 16 hours ago
Lens review: Olympus Zuiko 55mm F1.2
Latest: 19 hours ago
Just a bit of fun - bokeh spotting!
Latest: 2 days ago
Lens Review: Auto Sears/Sekor SX 55mm f/1.4
Latest: 2 days ago
Opteka 85mm f/1.8 EOS mount
Latest: 2 days ago
A question about making an old Canon AF Sigma lens into a 'manual' lens
Latest: 2 days ago
More...

Search this group's discussions

Lens Review: Cosina Wide-Angle 3.8/20 MC

view profile

LucisPictor says:

Name: Cosina Wide-Angle 3.8/20 MC
Mount: Nikon
Tested On: Canon EOS 350D / Canon EF-M
Zoom/Prime: Prime
Focal Length: 20mm
Maximum Aperture: f/3.8
Minimum Aperture: f/22
Diaphragm Blades: 5
Price Paid: € 55,-
Serial Number (or Approx.): 910xxxxx

Product Ratings (1=miserable, 5=excellent):
Construction Quality: 4
Image Quality: 3.5

Overall Value For Price: 4
Recommended: Yes, unless professional performance is needed

Lens Photos:



Review:
--------------------------------------------------------
My copy of this lens comes with the Nikon-F-mount and AI-functionality.
This lens is interesting since with its focal length of 20mm it provides wide angle photography even at a crop DSLR (at a Canon EOS 350D its FoV is similar to a 32mm lens at a full frame or film cam.)

The colours are nice and quite close to reality, contrast is fine but not too strong. The sharpness this lens produces is only mediocre and sometime leaves a bit to be wanted, especially when wide open. If you can shoot at f8, lack of sharpness is no issue any more.

Flaring is not a huge problem, either. In some difficult situations you can see some flares, but the coating seems to be a rather good one.

Some kind of drawback is the slight distortion. It is much better than you will find in most zoom lenses (even at 28mm) but it still is visible, also at a crop DSLR. So this Cosina is, as far as distortion is concerned, no match for the CZJ Flektogons which are much better corrected.

The best part of this lens is its price. You can get this lens for half the price of a Flek 4/20.

As a final verdict, I would say that the Cosina 3.8/20 will disappoint a pro but can be a very nice lens for somebody who looks for an affordable 20mm MF lens and is willing to accepts some faults that can be corrected with post-processing.
Originally posted at 11:33AM, 17 June 2008 PDT (permalink)
LucisPictor edited this topic 25 months ago.

view photostream

transiently permanent says:

This looks to be either the same as or very similar to the Cosina 19/3.8 which was sold in the 90's under their own and the Vivitar name.

As you said, the best thing about this lens is indeed probably its price (as long as you find it very, very cheaply). It is not a terrible lens, but the Cosina 24/2.8 from the same period and also sold as a Vivitar is a much better performer.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

silyavski says:

today i received an 4/20 Flektogon and a Cosina 24/2.8 Macro both from ebay. 240 versus 25e. 3:1 sized :-) My Surprise was that the Flek had Mediocre contrast and Sharpness. apart from this it had lousy and almost not working aperture.Though it looked like new with no obvious other problems. Yes it did had close to none distortion..
What an astonishment was the crisp and clear compared to the Flek performance of the little Cosina. I have seen better but no complains about the price though. Totally usable even for Pro images. It came in FD mount which i easy adapted for Om using the ring from a damaged Vivitar Miranda /same lens/ and then to EOS with an adapter.
So my 2 cents on this is that from 20 to 24mm there is No such difference like from 10 to 14mm. so go for the 24mm for a peace of mind or buy the 20mm Cosina reviewed here just for an experiment. It would save you nerves and money if you insist on an old Jena Flektogon like i stupidly did which is not well build as the half plastic Cosina.
Originally posted 40 months ago. (permalink)
silyavski edited this topic 40 months ago.

view photostream

LucisPictor says:

The problem with the Carl Zeiss Jena and all the other lenses made in the former GDR ist that you cannot rely on a constant buiding quality. If you get a good copy, you have an excellent glass. If not, it's probably a lemon.
Posted 40 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Schizoo from Paris is a group administrator Schizoo from Paris says:

I have a lemon :'(
Posted 40 months ago. (permalink)

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

RSS 2.0 feedSubscribe to a feed of stuff on this page...</!!> Feed – Subscribe to EOS Cameras and Manual Lenses discussion threads