Group Pool 66 items |   Only members can add to the pool. Join?

view profile
sam witney (a group admin) says:
06 Jun 07 - This is a new group...my first. It's just an experiment to see if there is any demand for deeper/higher quality critique of photos beyond number based scoring and throwaway remarks that can be found in other groups.

I hope you enjoy using it and look forward to seeing lots of your beautiful photos on here.

Sam

p.s. A personal bugbear of mine.... but please think twice before posting a picture of a flower or a cat. :-D

Discussion 0 posts |  Only members can post. Join?

No topics have been posted yet.


About Emotional Response Critique

This group is about gaining feedback on your pictures beyond "Nice picture" or "Should crop it".

This group is about posting pictures and asking viewers to do two things:

1. Tell you what their honest emotional response is to the picture is.
2. Explain what it is in the photo that creates that emotional response.

The aim of the group is for posters to get better quality feedback beyond % scores and inane comments and for viewrs to improve their ability to effectively critique a picture.

---------------------------------INSTRUCTIONS-------------------------------------------------------
Copy and paste this link onto each of the three photos immediately to the right of your own...delete the long lines and add your own thoughts:

Emotional Response: __
Why?: __
(from the <a href="http://www.flickr.com/groups/395084@N21/">Emotional Response Critique</a> group)

--------------------------------------------------------RULES---------------------------------------------------

Do :
- Follow the critical structure of posting your EMOTIONAL RESPONSE followed by an analysis of WHY the picture evokes that response.
- Post 1 and score the 3 to the RIGHT.(The immediate right!)
- Post your photo BEFORE scoring.
- Start scoring immediately after you have posted your photo.
- Wait until 3 more images have been posted after yours before posting another.
- Treat each other with respect.
- Be polite and constructive.

Don't:
- Flood the group
- Revenge Score
- Delete scores or comments
- Block other members
- Be abusive or make personal attacks on other posters images or in email
- Harass other members in any way
- Post images that you cannot claim authorship of
- Post nudity which shows sexual organs of any kind - nipples included - this is a family friendly group
- Remove your photos from the group

http://www.flickr.com/groups/emotional/

Additional Information

This group is public This is a public group.

  • View the group rules.
  • Members can post 10 things to the pool each day.
  • Accepted media types:
    • Photos
    • Video
  • Accepted content types:
    • Photos / Videos
    • Screenshots / Screencasts
    • Illustration/Art / Animation/CGI
  • Accepted safety levels:
    • Safe
RSS 2.0 feed Subscribe to a feed of stuff on this page... Feed – Subscribe to Emotional Response Critique discussion threads