You aren't signed in     Sign In    Help

DC Photo Rights / Discuss

Current Discussion

Here's a new one for ya...
Latest: 2 weeks ago
Spy Museum
Latest: 6 weeks ago
Federal Memo on Photography
Latest: 2 months ago
Union Station Security: Ignoring Sexual Harassment by Guards?
Latest: 2 months ago
What am I NOT allowed to photograph in DC?
Latest: 2 months ago
Amtrak Guidelines
Latest: 2 months ago
Another congressional hearing on photo harassment !!
Latest: 3 months ago
Transportation Walk Photographer Harassment (near National's Park)
Latest: 3 months ago
newbie photog & new to DC....
Latest: 4 months ago
Issue in Baltimore neighborhood
Latest: 5 months ago
The crazy police suspicion of photographers
Latest: 5 months ago
Station manager: "Please stop taking pictures of us driving trains"
Latest: 6 months ago
More...

Congressional hearing on Union Station, Tuesday, July 22

view profile

erin m is a group administrator erin m  Pro User  says:

I don’t have full details yet, and I promise to post them when I do. But yes, the subject header is correct: Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton is holding a hearing on Union Station that will focus in part on photographers’ rights and the incidents of harassment we’ve been discussing and documenting.

The hearing is scheduled for next Tuesday, July 22, at 10 a.m. in Rayburn 2167. It’s the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, Subcommittee on Economic Development, Public Buildings, and Emergency Management.

There’s a possibility C-SPAN will pick it up if there’s nothing more interesting going on, and the committee webcasts most of its hearings.

While incidents at Union Station have become increasingly rare, there are currently no guarantees that they won't start up again. I hope the hearing will result in the people who run the station adopting and publicizing a sensible photography policy and making sure their guards know what it is. That's all we've ever wanted.

This happened because of everyone here who contacted Norton’s office after the Fox 5 incident and everyone who reported the incidents that got Fox 5, the Post’s Marc Fisher and DCist and all the other local blogs and message boards to pay attention to this issue in the first place. So thank you, everyone who has supported to and contributed to this group.

I wonder if they'll let us bring our cameras to the hearing?
Originally posted at 5:19PM, 14 July 2008 PST ( permalink )
erin m edited this topic 18 months ago.

view photostream

katmere is a group administrator katmere  Pro User  says:

I'll have to see if I can get off work! I'd love to sit in on this. This is fantastic, it's great to see such momentum taking shape. I second Erin's comments, great work to *everyone* who has been involved in moving this issue forward!
Posted 18 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Patrick J. Casey  Pro User  says:

Just checked transportation.house.gov/hearings/hearing.aspx?NewsID=708 - the hearing will be webcast.
Posted 18 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

erin m is a group administrator erin m  Pro User  says:

As promised, here are more details.

This is a PDF of the hearing summary, including a short intro and a list of people giving testimony.

LightboxDC promises to blog about the hearing tomorrow as well.
Originally posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )
erin m edited this topic 17 months ago.

view photostream

JRSlater  Pro User  says:

Wow, all those big names and one private photographer! Go get 'em! LOL

Good luck!

Jeff
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

katmere is a group administrator katmere  Pro User  says:

I won't be able to make it, so I look forward to LIghtboxDC's comments.
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

HeatherMG  Pro User  says:

Knock 'em dead, Erin.
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Brian Knight Photography  Pro User  says:

Erin you rocked at the big show today! Way to go.
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Miscelena  Pro User  says:

Oh, the drama... oh the suspense! How'd it go? Was there butt-kicking as well as rocking?! *grin*

Seriously though - so pleased that you were given an opportunity to comment, and I'm sure I'm not the only one eager to hear what was said! (Me: stuck in office with computer with no speakers... bah!)
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

lightboxdc is a group administrator lightboxdc says:

Congresswoman Norton seriously schooled Union Station's managers today, on photography and a number of other issues. As a former longtime congressional staffer, I can assuredly state this: Erin McCann testified like a pro, and the managers had a very, very bad day:

greatergreaterwashington.org/post.cgi?id=1066

www.flickr.com/photos/lightboxdc/2692781529/in/photostream/
Originally posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )
lightboxdc (a group admin) edited this topic 17 months ago.

view photostream

erin m is a group administrator erin m  Pro User  says:

Well that was fun! I've posted some photos of my own, and I promise to write a bit more when the adrenaline finally leaves my system.

For starters, this is my oral statement before the subcommittee.

This is the rest of the statement I submitted, which is a timeline of my involvement in the issue and some of the worst incidents.

The statement is posted on a blog I set up about six weeks ago and then promptly ignored. I promise not to do that anymore.

This is a video to the full hearing.

I went first, but you should keep watching for a bit after that. Norton continues to hammer the three men who testified after me on the issue of photo rights in Union Station. She is especially displeased at their attempts to claim it is private property.

More later.
Originally posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )
erin m edited this topic 17 months ago.

view photostream

philliefan99  Pro User  says:

You're famous now. ;)
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

shashinka-ichiban says:

You know what annoys me though in all this, is everything will get as short term resolve, and in the end, 6 months or a eyar later after it all blows over, we're going to be right back in the same boat. I hate to sound negative, but I've been down this road so many times shooting in DC, with security, the police, and the lawyers only to run right back in to the same wall xxxx time later.
Originally posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )
shashinka-ichiban edited this topic 17 months ago.

view photostream

docblase says:

Erin, thanks for posting the video. The hearing starts at 21:30 for those wanting to get to the actual beginning of Ms. Norton's opening statement.
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

lightboxdc is a group administrator lightboxdc says:

Fox5 report:

www.myfoxdc.com/myfox/pages/News/Detail?contentId=7037395...
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

erin m is a group administrator erin m  Pro User  says:

I'm picking through some of the Web posts that have picked this up already, and this one is one of my favorites, mostly because it's just a 40-second clip of Norton apologizing to all of us for the insane treatment we've gotten from Union Station representatives this year.

What she says: “As a member of Congress who represents this city, I want to offer my apologies to the amateur photographers who have experienced this treatment in a facility that enjoys the patronage of the Congress of the United States through funding. And we’re having this hearing obviously not only because of your complaints but because we haven’t had a hearing on Union Station and when you leave people alone for decades, then they develop their own policies. That ceases today.”

Originally posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )
erin m edited this topic 17 months ago.

view photostream

erin m is a group administrator erin m  Pro User  says:

And, finally for tonight, Washington Post has their story up.
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Alt.Frames  Pro User  says:

In the FOX5 report, an interesting reason as to why so much harassment happens is because of high-turnover rates of security guards.

This is MUCH more relevant to a "security issue" than photography. Why is there a high-turnover rate? Low pay? Lack of benefits? Lack of morale? If the very people who are supposed to watch out for "real" security risks (usually fights, minor disturbances) keep on quitting, then doesn't that affect overall security?

Perhaps along with making a clear photography policy (ie, photography allowed everywhere), Jones Lang La Salle should focus on their hiring and retention practices.
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

lightboxdc is a group administrator lightboxdc says:

Bingo, Alt. At Union Station and facilities nationwide, we have security theater, not real security. What are security paid? How are they trained? What are they missing while they are accosting a shutterbug?
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Alt.Frames  Pro User  says:

It seems to me like an interesting angle for the Washington Post/local news to cover.
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Oblivious Dude  Pro User  says:

Whoa, congratulations Erin and other tireless photo reformers! Talk about turnabout!
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Miscelena  Pro User  says:

Awesome, you guys. That quote is fantastic. Congrats!
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

let 'er rip says:

Nice work on getting some results...

Here's our blog post about it (with great photo by Sanjay Suchak):

discarted.wordpress.com/2008/07/23/congress-weighs-in-on-...
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

rustybytes says:

Can you give out medals for this? Erin, you deserve one...congratulations and well done
Posted 17 months ago. ( permalink )

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

RSS 2.0 feedSubscribe to a feed of stuff on this page...</!!> Feed – Subscribe to DC Photo Rights discussion threads
Add to My Yahoo!