Critique and Comment

Discussion 4 posts |  Only members can post. Join?

About Critique and Comment

Welcome to the group! This group is for people who enjoy giving and receiving feedback on photos, who like to have a fun time (duh!), AND WHO ARE HONEST(ly nice people).

Critique and comment works like this: Once you post your photo to the pool, you must immediately comment on EITHER 3, 4, or 5, photos that come right before your own photo in the pool. In other words, while other comment groups require for you to write comments on a set number of photos, this group lets you make a choice.

Here's the catch:
If you write 5 comments, they MUST be decent. "Decent" means your comment must AT LEAST fill up the space in the comment box.
If your write 4 comments, they MUST be better than decent. "Better than decent" means a really good and well-rounded comment (verging on critique) of each photo. Multiple paragraphs (however short) are suggested.
If you write 3 comments, you MUST write a full-fledged critique. If you choose to write 3 comments, you better make sure that they're good! Writing three comments in this group WILL take more effort than writing five.

TO MAKE THE GROUP WORK, PLEASE FOLLOW THESE RULES! THE CALIBER OF YOUR CHARACTER MIGHT BE AT STAKE! IF YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS, GO TO A DIFFERENT GROUP!

Sorry 'bout this, but just please make sure you follow these basic rules as well (and that'll be it for rules –promise!) :

1. If you fail to write comments immediately after you post your photo, you will be removed from the group. If you reenter the group and again break the rules, you get BANNED!
2. You must add the Group Tag to every comment you give.
3. You MUST WAIT FOR FIVE PHOTOS to be posted after yours BEFORE you can post another photo. (Even if you choose to post 3 or 4 comments, you must still wait for at least 5 photos to be entered into the pool before you post another one of your photos.) You will be BANNED if you do not follow this rule.
4. If the person before you has posted more than one shot at a time, ignore their photos completely and skip over them. Their photos will be deleted imminently.
4. No porn.
5. No being STUPID! (That basically means comply with the rules and have a good time.)
6. Have fun!!!

GROUP TAG:
Please use the following code to identify your comments (between the dashed lines):

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
<a
href="http://www.flickr.com/groups/critiqueandcomment/"><img
src="http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3211/2819686070_6906ce5375_o.jpg"
width="173" height="45" /></a>
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------


It will look like this:





Please check out the threads. There will be contests and discussions and awesome stuff that you should join.