You aren't signed in     Sign In    Help

FlickrCentral / Discuss

Current Discussion

Look through the photostream of the person above you and choose your favourite
Latest: 19 minutes ago
What's the reason to hide EXIF?
Latest: 20 minutes ago
New group announcements!
Latest: 35 minutes ago
Its Tough to be a Photographer
Latest: 46 minutes ago
Camera Finder vs. Explore
Latest: 60 minutes ago
take a picture from the photostream above you, and say a song it reminds you of
Latest: 2 hours ago
Does anyone know Photrade?
Latest: 3 hours ago
Lumix DMC-LX3
Latest: 4 hours ago
Now Public is Now Pointless (or maybe just Now Spam?)
Latest: 4 hours ago
The Library of Congress vs. the DMCA, DRM, and Copyright Restrictions
Latest: 5 hours ago
MediaStorm.org
Latest: 5 hours ago
Self introductions!
Latest: 7 hours ago
More...
spacer image

I predict Google will buy Flickr in February 2005

view profile

ThatAdamGuy  Pro User  says:

You can read my full set of arguments on my BLADAM entry about Google's gaping image data hole, but just in case you're feeling lazy, here's a summary:

1) Google has Picasa, which offers a very comfortable way for people to organize photos on their hard drive. It also has an online image database. But there's no link between the two.

2) Google's Image database severely lacks metadata. Via Picasa 2.0 (coming up), I'm sure that there'll be an easy way for users to enter in such metadata and have it transferred to an online gallery. Voila ;).

3) Flickr is well respected by Bloggers and by many Googlers.

4) Open API!

5) Flickr has the sort of feel, the management (from what I can tell), and the underpinnings of a companies that Google likes.

6) Tags. Very Gmail like. Very smart.

I go into more detail in my blog entry.

I'd love to hear your thoughts on all of this :)
Posted at 1:02AM, 19 December 2004 PDT ( permalink )

view photostream

fubuki  Pro User  says:

yup - total googlebait - the feb2005 deadline though might be a little tight. who knows though...
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

*Seuss*  Pro User  says:

When ludi sells it off to a player like google that will be the end of my interest in it.

Hopefully ludi wouldn't even think of selling a commodity like Flickr.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

striatic is a group administrator striatic  Pro User  says:

google will build it themselves out of hello/picasa + blogger

yahoo needs flickr much more than google does.

i wouldn't be surprised if yahoo has already made an offer.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

ThatAdamGuy  Pro User  says:

TheSeuss, I'd respectfully suggest that's a bit unfair.

Look at Blogger. It went from being a fine service with extra-cost premium features to an excellent, more robust, and completely free service. Google kept the Blogger team intact, and built upon the team's successes rather than scrapping the service for parts.

I have no insider knowledge with either Flickr or Google, but I can say pretty confidently that Google would only improve upon an already excellent service.

Why do you feel differently?

And Striatic... I'd note that Google doesn't have a very good track record in integration. Can you point to a single set of services that they've integrated really well? Gmail and Groups? Groups and Orkut? Don't think so.

Sure, there's Hello/Picasa/Blogger, but the Blogger UI / infrastructure does not seem well suited for galleries or flexible-permission sharing.

But you do raise the point that Yahoo may indeed be gunning for Flickr, too ;)
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

*Seuss*  Pro User  says:

Let's just say I like small teams in small companies far more than small teams in large companies. That and I am far more confident in Ludicorp improving upon their excellent service than counting on anyone else to do the same.

PS. I don't like blogger & never have but I find it less palatable under google.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

striatic is a group administrator striatic  Pro User  says:

yahoo has yahoo photos, which could really use some big improvements in my opinion. yahoo has a solid history with yahoo groups, and i think that flickr fits into the groups model very well.

i think you underestimate flickr's independence. they have apparently turned down acquisition offers before, and you shouldn't assume that they really want to be google's second banana.

maybe they will or maybe they won't, but there is nothing 'natural' about google+flickr. any acquistion of flickr would take much shoehorning to effect.

i wouldn't bet on it.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

striatic is a group administrator striatic  Pro User  says:

and google doesn't need to acquire flickr to get at the metadata and images, that part of your case is a bit tenuous. if google is interested in flickr, it is as a service plain and simple.

it isn't like they bought blogger so they could index the blog posts there. they were doing that regardless.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

striatic is a group administrator striatic  Pro User  says:

finally, google doesn't need the existing userbase of flickr.

"brought to you by google" generates instant userbase {see orkut or gmail}

"brought to you by yahoo" does not. flickr could really help them out in that respect.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

Maked [deleted] says:

I'd like to see Google buy Microsoft. That would be a switch.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

intutum says:

hey bouyz and girrls...

here is something

EPIC

it is pain to load on my machine, but if you get to the end of it... you might wonder a bit.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

GustavoG  Pro User  says:

intutum, thanks for sharing that. It's excellent.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

striatic is a group administrator striatic  Pro User  says:

ha ha .. the EPIC thing.

i half died laughing when i first watched that.

the "this will merge with that" is hilarious speculation, especially the names they come up with for the merged companies. the narration is also extremely over the top.

the idea of algorithmically written news stories, however, is a very interesting one.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

ThatAdamGuy  Pro User  says:

I was really disappointed in that "EPIC" presentation. I think there are so many fascinating issues to discuss regarding personalization, privacy, cultural sharing, and so on... and this movie was all gloss, little substance.

Issues that could have been addressed:
- Even today, many people simply read the Sports section and ignore the Business or Travel or even Top Stories sections of newspapers. People are "personalizing" already.
- How might increased personalization increase or decrease global awareness?
- Would such changes in the news radically change international politics?
- Would people spend more time consuming the news each day? Less?
- Would Googlezon be intensely regulated by the federal government?
- Who would pay the up-front costs of in-depth investigation reports?
...and many more.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

GustavoG  Pro User  says:

many people simply read the Sports section

That's perfectly fine with me. You see, I never read the Sports section. Sharing the paper with those people becomes a nice, happy bridge between my world and theirs.

(indeed, I'm not being serious)
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Ol' Mr Boston  Pro User  says:

I predict Flickr will buy Google in 2006!! =0)
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

vista  Pro User  says:

I'd like to see Google buy Flickr.

Yaya, sounds cool...
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

intutum says:

1. great that some of you got to watch the EPIC thing, and comment on it. it has been circulating for a while in the blogosphere.
2. such future scenarios always have a very high probability of being wrong, like most speculation.
3. i have no clue who actually authored the script on it, my guess is that it was not Microsoft.

I have no clue as to what Google and Flickr will do, in either the near future or further down the line, however the speculation on this discussion has been entertaining.

To my knowledge Google has one serious competitor... one that nobody ever mentions. So I am curious what they will do in all of this.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

ThatAdamGuy  Pro User  says:

Are you speaking of Yahoo, or...?
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

GustavoG  Pro User  says:

Heh, no, not Yahoo.
intutum is talking about... you know, them.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

quas says:

Ludicorp, obviously.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

intutum says:

i know them, i know the technology, and i know google fears them, so much so that not a word is ever mentioned about them. there is a stealth somewhere in the semantic web. go find it!
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

rvacapinta  Pro User  says:

They're generally not talked about in this space, but you're right intutum.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

ve3cnu [deleted] says:

Good call Adam!

betterdigitalphotography.blogspot.com/2004/12/flickr-gets...
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

Maked [deleted] says:

Ok, I'll bite. WHO IS "THEM"?
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

purplezebra  Pro User  says:

I believe the founders of blogger have left Google. Small company cultures into big company cultures very rarely work well, no matter how "great" said big company is to work for. Subsequently, the culture of the product that was purchased changes as well, for better and worse.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

Maked [deleted] says:

EVERY business starts out small, even Microsoft was once small. Apple started out in a living room and garage. It's a myth that business "just appear". Almost all businesses start with one person and idea. True, most don't become giants, but those that do are usually started by "nobodies" with an idea who become giants of industry, art, science, or in whatever field they excel.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

purplezebra  Pro User  says:

Of course all companies start out small, but that doesn't change the fact that big company cultures are different than small company cultures. Different employees want/require different types of work environments and office politics. Even as small companies get larger, they start to see attrition from employees with less than 3 digit ID numbers.

In addition, "small" products/companies that have been acquired by a larger company will see some improvements and some mishaps after the acquisition. Unless, of course, you're IBM, where the mantra is, all acquisitions will fail miserably. Lotus Notes being a prime example.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

ThatAdamGuy  Pro User  says:

It's my understanding that -- of the Blogger folks who came over to Google initially (most of them, I believe) -- only one has left. That's Evan (Evhead), and he left within the last month or two.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

FriskoDude says:

I think Evan left several months ago, as I remember his farewell notice on Blogger. That said, I use Blogger for my blog and think it's excellent -- never crashed and I've never had a single piece of spam. How's that MT? And it's free, which I have no objection to.

The short side is that Blogger has very little interactivity, which is the strong suit of Flickr. So a merger of Google/Blogger and Flickr, in my opinion, would be a good thing, although Flickr in it's current state is doing just fine.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

purplezebra  Pro User  says:

I'd have to agree with FriskoDude about Blogger. I like it too, though it sometimes gets really, really slow, or at worst, inaccessible, but other than that it's a great basic blogging tool sans spam.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

eh_notsomuch [deleted] says:

Good prediction. I'll take a piece of that action.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

D4rkst4r says:

I believe intutum has the where-with-all to read inbetween the lines...
A small fact to be considered...The NSA has placed 12 multi-blade terabit storage capable servers (bought from RLX Technologies,inc.) into Google's new Atlanta facility...
Do you really think that gmail is being "read" solely for targeting ads at you ?
or perhaps you are being databased to the extremes already, with the Govt profiling you illegally ?
I say boycott Google NOW. Let's just see how quickly they do imitate Amazon by selling all customers personal info to ChoicePoint, inc. whose main customer is the Govt. Poindexter's TIA lives...and WE the people are the victims of lost privacy !
See : EPIC.org
or : EFF.org
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

ThatAdamGuy  Pro User  says:

> The NSA has placed 12 multi-blade terabit storage capable servers (bought
> from RLX Technologies,inc.) into Google's new Atlanta facility...

Cite from an authoritative source?

> Do you really think that gmail is being "read" solely for tageting ads at you ?

Yes.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

D4rkst4r says:

thatadamguy:
>Cite from an authoritative source?

inside info from both companies...

>> Do you really think that gmail is being "read" solely for tageting ads at you ?

>Yes.

dual nic cards in promiscuious mode hooked directly from NSA servers to gmail servers....
You are wrong !
(fyi: I found this site via your page via a mutual friend's page... I am surprised you don't have more of a clue!)
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

Maked [deleted] says:

D4rkst4t, that's odd..........the only EFF HACKER CON I've ever been to in my life was in ATLANTA. I'm not joking. In fact, it's every year, during DragonCon. Maybe the EFF is really a tool of the government trying to fool us all?

If Google is really working with the NSA, I'm betting someone inside Google will BLOG it.

Now, I'm all for paranoia, but unless you can back it up with facts, it's meaningless.


Let's see. Earthlink is in Atlanta.......Apple owns part of Earthlink...... Ted Turner is Atlanta, who owns CNN, and the Atlanta Braves. I'm betting the "Tomahawk Chop" is some sort of secret cyber signal to the "in control" Illuminati watching in some remote location in inside the Hills of Western Georgia who report directly to Guantanimo Bay that is relayed by satellite to Baghdad then double looped back to Washington. Or something like that.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

dogsbody  Pro User  says:

Ha! Good one lhc1 - you're pretty funny when you lighten up :-)
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

Maked [deleted] says:

Dogs, I'm always lightened up. I guess you just NEVER got the joke. And, the Hacker Con I refer to is real, as are at least two more Hacker Cons each year in Atlanta. If fact, if FLICKR wants a lesson in Cons, ask the DragonCon folks for advice. It's truly one of the most unreal events around. People fly from all over the country, Canada, and Europe for this event. It's not just big. It's a monster.
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

D4rkst4r says:

lhc1:
it's the EFGA, not EFF that runs a track at DragonCon. The EFF has provided speakers for the track. The track is not
a "hackers" track even though it includes some hackers panels. It's an information track dealing with issues encountered in conjunction with the internet.

There is only one hacker con in Atlanta now days: Interz0ne

and perhaps I may just be the informed source ? and this may be the whistle blow blog.......
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

Maked [deleted] says:

The InterZone guy was at the last computer event I was at during DragonCon. I have seen advertisements for other Hacker Cons in Atlanta, but never attended. Of course the Con I'm really going to miss after next year is Fantasm, since it is the last year. They just keep getting kicked out of hotels, year after year. Oh well, all things must end. I guess it will go the way of Sanctuary.....have we met at DragonCon?
Posted 44 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

~C4Chaos  Pro User  says:

makes sense to me. let's wait and see. but i like to see 1.0 first :)
Posted 43 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

ThatAdamGuy  Pro User  says:

Looks like, at least in the short term, I was mistaken. I hope the ludicorpians forgive me ;-)
Posted 43 months ago. ( permalink )

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

RSS 2.0 feedSubscribe to a feed of stuff on this page...</!!> Feed – Subscribe to FlickrCentral discussion threads
Add to My Yahoo!