Canon DSLR User Group / Discuss

Current Discussion

journalist who used a photo of mine without asking!
Latest: 19 minutes ago
Recommended wide-angle prime for street on 5Dii
Latest: 2 hours ago
Please help!
Latest: 3 hours ago
mkii vs mkiii
Latest: 3 hours ago
A shot untouched - a digitally enhanced image - should we split?
Latest: 4 hours ago
Canon 40D, battery grip and battery usage question
Latest: 5 hours ago
Here,s the dpreview of 5D Mk III
Latest: 7 hours ago
Wedding photography
Latest: 10 hours ago
Off on Safari with the 450d, need a tele lens!
Latest: 11 hours ago
Lenses: Original vs Generic
Latest: 13 hours ago
lens suitable for Street Photography
Latest: 14 hours ago
Online Magazine Used My Photo
Latest: 16 hours ago
More...

Search this group's discussions

Which Canon is the top of the heap?

view profile

DWRowan  Pro User  says:

OK, everyone is very excited about the new EOS-1D Mark III. Yes, clearly it has a lot of new technology behind it, but....

The EOS-1Ds Mark II still shoots higher resolution (16mp) and uses traditional lens calculations (That is, a 50mm lens acts like a 50mm lens) so all your pre-digital stuff works without doing any math.

Now, I just broke the bank buying a 30D, so both of these bad boys are out of my reach. I was just wondering which would be considered the "Flagship" camera.

I understand that the Mark III is going to have the newest technology, but it seems more like a replacment for the old EOS-1D Mark II N. So should we expect to see a 1Ds-Mark III with a larger sensor and double the pixels?

Speculation?
Posted at 6:37PM, 21 May 2007 PDT (permalink)

view photostream

scubapup is a group administrator scubapup says:

they are targeted towards different uses so there is no use comparing the 1ds and the 1d

and yes do expect a 1ds mark iii in the near future
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

geniusofnati says:

what type of photos do you want to take, because 1ds mark II and III are built for sports photography, and to give you the high fps, and boy is it fast.....but the other im not so sure...higher mega pix means more processing per photo which means the colors may be more accurate, i guess
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

BennehBoy  Pro User  says:

I shoot a 1dmkii, and use it for parkour and tricking shots, it suits me well. Anthything else I shoot with a 5D.
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Aeshec says:

I still want a 5D!
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Rehuel says:

@geniusofnati: 1Ds MKII is not built for sports. It only shoots 4 fps and is a full frame 16.7 megapixel camera. The 1D MKII N is the sports camera with a 1.3X crop and 8.5 fps and 8.2 megapixels. To me, it sounds like the Mark III is a replacement for the Mark IIN and not the 1Ds Mark II.
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

zlguocius says:

I'd suggest a good operational criterion to determine which model is the "flagship" is to see which one costs the most.
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Todd Klassy  Pro User  says:

Top of the heap? The 1Ds Mark III, coming to a store near you very, very soon.
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Steve.Korn  Pro User  says:

Holga!
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

zettpress  Pro User  says:

From trusted sources I heard that a 1ds mk III with a larger (24 MP sensor) was/is in the works but the Canon guys realized that they would create all kinds of problems with it.

- Now their lenses seem to be the bottleneck as these were unable to deliver the details needed for 24 MP.

- The additional file size (factor 1.5) slowed down the speed and number of frames that could be taken in a row.

That makes the step from 1D mk IIN to 1D mk III appear much more logical.

FWIW, I'll stick with the 1ds mk II and the 1D mk IIN. Right now I do not see the need to upgrade. For me, and from an image quality point-of-view the 1Ds mk II is still "the top of the heap".
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

de|me|tris:  Pro User  says:

Some might say there is no 'flagship'.

The two models you mention are targeted at entirely different markets.

It's as ludicrous as asking is a landscape/portrait photographer more important than a sports/photojournalist.

If you want to make a step up from the 30D - the camera that broke your bank - head towards a 5D.

Otherwise start shooting more so you'll have a need for one of Canon's flagship 1 series models.
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

tim_walls  Pro User  says:

Canon's flagship is the 1V, shurely? (I'll get me coat...)
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

_mpd_ [deleted] says:

I second the Holga, but the pinhole spameras gets up there too.
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

The Real Bear  Pro User  says:

350d rules!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted 61 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

scubapup is a group administrator scubapup says:

hey this thread was mentioned thanks to zetpress' reply lol

www.northlight-images.co.uk/Canon_1DS_MkIII.html

lol
Originally posted 61 months ago. (permalink)
scubapup (a group admin) edited this topic 61 months ago.

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

RSS 2.0 feedSubscribe to a feed of stuff on this page...</!!> Feed – Subscribe to Canon DSLR User Group discussion threads