HDR Tutorial / Discuss

Current Discussion

High Dynamic Range (HDR) Tutorial using 1 JPG
Latest: 46 months ago
Fixing The Halo and Processing Techniques In Photoshop...
Latest: 46 months ago
More...

Search this group's discussions

Fixing The Halo and Processing Techniques In Photoshop...

view profile

Ryan Eng is a group administrator Ryan Eng says:

:: The Why ::

I've made this tutorial to teach people how to create an HDR image and show how to fix that nasty halo that Photomatix creates around objects with simple blending. My overall goal is to achieve a more "natural" looking HDR photo using some basic DRI (aka Digital Blending) and Photoshop layer masks. In my brief HDR journey I've come across hundreds of decent HDR photos that could have been real masterpieces if they had just spent a little extra time in Photoshop. Now for those of you who like that 'halo' in your photos and like extremely fake looking HDR's then this tutorial probably will not help much.

Before and After.
- The left image is the tone mapped file straight from Photomatix 3 with no Photoshop adjustments. The right image has been fixed with digital blending, a layer of curves, saturation, an unsharp mask of 100 at 50% opacity.


- Click Image To See Larger




Equipment used for this tutorial
- Nikon D90
- Sigma 10-20mm
- Photomatix v3.0
- Adobe Photoshop CS2 (CS3 or higher makes it easier with the Quick Selection tool)


This is my first tutorial so hopefully it makes sense. I'll try to make it as straight forward as possible If you notice any errors, have any suggestions, or have any questions, please post here and I will reply. Thanks.




:: The How ::

- Step 1
Keep the camera on Aperture Priority mode, turn Auto Bracket on and shoot the different exposures. With the Nikon D90 the easiest way to bracket more than 3 exposures is by using the Exposure Compensation button. Set it to -1 and auto bracket 3 exposures, then quickly set it to 0 and auto bracket 3 exposures, finally set it to +1 and auto bracket 3 exposures. When you're done you'll have (-3,-2,-1,0,+1,+2,+3) and an extra -1,+1 which you can just delete.


- Step 2
Generate HDR in Photomatix using Detail Enhancer. You can use any settings you want. I'm still not even sure what the optimal settings are yet. The red arrows are the halo that photomatix creates. This is what we will be fixing.


- Step 3
Open the Photomatix tone mapped file along with the -2 and 0 exposure into Photoshop and copy/paste the two exposures onto the tone mapped file. (You can use any exposure to blend onto the tone mapped file. If it's too dark or too light you can change the opacity or use the paint brush on a low opacity to paint on the layer mask itself.)


- Step 4
Select the areas of the tone mapped file that have the halo with any of the selection tools (Quick Select in CS3 an CS4 is the easiest). Once you have that area selected apply a feather of 5-10px and click the 'apply layer mask' button. If you need to add more of the mask or take away some just use the paint brush and change the opacity to the desired level. Use the color White to reveal more of the selected exposure or Black to hide. Then select the layer mask of that layer and paint where needed.



- Step 5
Once you've reduced the halo and achieved a desired look it's time to finish it off. Apply a layer mask and make the diagonal line in a slight S curve. Add a layer of saturation. And if you want to sharpen the image a bit just merge all the photo layers together and go to Filter>Sharpen>Unsharp Mask. Set it anywhere from 100-200. A LucisArt filter called Wheyth has similar effects with some contrast.

- Click Image To See Larger


- Final Image






:: You ::

Hope this tutorial has helped anyone with this problem. Please feel free to comment or add suggestions below.
- Ryan Eng.



.
Originally posted at 9:56AM, 24 November 2008 PDT (permalink)
Ryan Eng edited this topic 55 months ago.

view photostream

Ryan Eng is a group administrator Ryan Eng says:

.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

|sumsion|  Pro User  says:

You're awesome Ryan. It's great to have all of this in one place. Thanks for posting this for everybody.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Mike G. K.  Pro User  says:

Thanx for the great info.
I was always having problems with the Halos and the only thing I could do was to to increase one or more of the following settings in photomatix: Light smoothing, luminosity, White point, mirco smoothing and/or highlights smoothing but this was reducing the HDR effect.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Mike G. K.  Pro User  says:

Also, it's interesting that you are placing the original photos above the HDR. I was putting the original photo below the HDR and creating a layer mask on the HDR layer. I wonder if this has the same effect or not.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Mike G. K.  Pro User  says:

Last thing: I would like to have some more info about how you create the selection and how it can be created more easily with quick mask as you mention (if you have some more time).

Thanx again !
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Ryan Eng is a group administrator Ryan Eng says:

I've done a few HDR's where I actually tone map 2 different files with photomatix on different settings. Lets say tone map one where the sky looks best, then tone map another of that same photo where the foreground looks the best. Then digitally blend both tone mapped files together in photoshop.

The easiest way to make the selection is with the Quick Select tool in CS3. Since my computer broke I'm using a laptop with only CS2 and it doesn't have the Quick Select tool so I used the magic wand with a tolerance between 30 and 60. Then you just select the halo area. Let's say you select the sky and it selects the entire sky including the halo area. That's okay. Just layer mask the whole sky and then use the paint brush to paint black, on the layer mask, on the parts of the sky around the halo that you want to get rid of. That will let the tone mapped file underneath show thru.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Mike G. K.  Pro User  says:

Thanx!
I have to try it.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

[ Kane ]  Pro User  says:

Nice mate, thanks for PS tips, I get that problem a bit, not too much, but a bit, now I need to see if I can do all that is PS 6.0 ;) haha can do ;)
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

tinaadventure says:

Thanks Ryan. The tutorial is a huge help and will hopefully inspire me to the next level.
I just want to know how you got that chicken to stay still for all those exposures? I'm sure it would have moved on me as I fumbled through it all.
Great job!
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Ryan Eng is a group administrator Ryan Eng says:

Haha. I got really lucky. I think I shot this same set of 3 exposures like 5 different times one after another until I got one without movement.
Posted 55 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Eric Rousset  Pro User  says:

Thanks Ryan for this tuto, really helpful ;-))
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Matt Romack Photography says:

Interesting, did you develop this technique yourself?
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Ryan Eng is a group administrator Ryan Eng says:

I don't know if I developed it, but I learned it on my own. Had a few helpful hints and tips from a few hdr masters on flickr.
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Josh JCW images says:

How do you get an HDR of a moving object? Is it possible to create one from a single image? I've tried it by adjusting the brightness after the fact in photoshop with decent results, but I'd like better.
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Ryan Eng is a group administrator Ryan Eng says:

Yes its possible. Just shoot in raw format. When you open that file in adobe camera raw change the exposure to -2 then save the file, then change the exposure to 0 save another one, then change it to +2 and save that. Then you'll have 3 exposures to make an hdr.
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Mike G. K.  Pro User  says:

also, if your camera does not have RAW capabilities you can even create an HDR from a single jpg. Have a look at:
www.flickr.com/groups/single_jpg_hdr/discuss/721576049215...
Posted 54 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

gracust  Pro User  says:

Fabulous tutorial. I know the basics but you have just enlightened me further. Thanks for sharing.
Posted 53 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

bcrichason says:

I know this is probably the more tedious way...but could you use the dodge and burn feature to get rid of the halo?
Posted 53 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

vedd  Pro User  says:

Just want to share with you a trick of mine. My approach would be creating 2 tone maps from the same set of exposures.

One with Light Smoothing is set to high and the other one is set to very high. Using high and very high will minimize the halos greatly plus your picture will be more natural looking (if that is what you trying to achieve) :-)

Luminosity is set at 0 for both. If the image is too dark/bright, play with gamma/white points/black points instead of Luminosity. This way you'll minimize noise (to a certain degree, obviously hehe).

For the two set of tone maps, you can blend them using layer masks or like me, use smart objects to blend them together.

Hope this will be useful to you guys :-) Happy HDR'ing, tonemapping and blending :-)

v
Posted 53 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Jimbography ;-)  Pro User  says:

Very interresting, thanks for this ryan!
Posted 53 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

scott howse  Pro User  says:

Good tutorial Ryan, thank you, one that I will pay attention to for the sake of knowledge and forwarding my techniques.

As with Yedd, I usually find (in Photomatix) if you set the Light Smoothing to 4 (I see 3 is selected above) this cuts the halo down substantially compared to 3, and even more so if you set the Light Smoothing to 5 (far right button). For the sake of constantly changing around I always usually have my Light Smoothing set to 4.

I think you should start doing some Youtube tutorials, makes it easier for basic learners like myself to understand.

Rgds

Scott
Posted 53 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Allaninva2008  Pro User  says:

Very Good Tutorial. I've read many tutorials on capturing and processing HDR's and it's apparent there are many ways to solve certain issues. It looks like your technique for halo's appears to be easier, depending on the amount of halos, and also has some added flexibility.
Posted 52 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Boris Mitendorfer Photography  Pro User  says:

Thank for all the help you give us here, Ryan. I will for sure try this technics on my shot some day in the future!
Thank's also to all others for their tricks with hdr practice!
Posted 52 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Gines.Photography says:

Thanks Ryan!
Hats off to guys like you who are willing to share tips and tricks. This is very good! I'm going out on a shoot right now =)
Posted 52 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Gertjan de Vries  Pro User  says:

Many thanks for sharing this excellent tutorial.

After having been struggling for a long time I finally can get rid of those halos now :-)
Posted 51 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

busb  Pro User  says:

I use the Magic wand & related selection tools in PSP9. A mixture of feathering, shrinking or inverting the selections to get the desired effect.
Most of my current tone mapping is done on single jpg images in Photomatix then the resulting tif files edited in PSP. Although this technique works better than it has any right to - working with such a limited dynamic range can product some unwanted effects such as lifted shadow areas being desaturated. Other areas I tend to select then feather are dark patches in the sky or areas of white that have well-defined boarders but similar adjacent features are much darker or lighter.
I find another powerful tool in Photomatix to reduce haloing or grey patches is to adjust the Highlights smoothing from its default zero or just not use too little Light Smoothing to start with without compromising the effect too much.
This fine tutorial should help people to produce better work. I too see many HDR images on flickr that could be awesome if a little more work was done on them. I would like to link this to my HDR Notes if I may:
www.flickr.com/photos/busb/2343466265/
Originally posted 50 months ago. (permalink)
busb edited this topic 50 months ago.

view photostream

Mark McDowell says:

Thanks for the awesome tutorial!
Posted 47 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Boom Got Em says:

Thanks nice tutorial. Cant wait to actually give it a shot..keep it up?
Posted 46 months ago. (permalink)

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

RSS 2.0 feedSubscribe to a feed of stuff on this page...</!!> Feed – Subscribe to HDR Tutorial discussion threads