Group Pool 54 items |   Only members can add to the pool. Join?

» More photos

view profile
Nerboo (a group admin) says:
06 Jun 11 - Post a photo for critique. It's that simple. BUT YOU MUST critique the photo immediately next to yours in the group pool. Don't be dick and fail to do so. And feel free to comment on more than just the photo next to yours.

Be harsh, but be fair. And don't pat someone on the back when it's really a shit pic.

And make sure you post you saw the pic in the No Fluff group so other viewers of the photo don't think you are an ass. Then again, you may be an ass....

Discussion 6 posts |  Only members can post. Join?

Title Author Replies Latest Post
There must be DICKS among us! Southern Scene Photography 0 11 months ago
Ok I am confused Southern Scene Photography 9 11 months ago
Additions to the Pool Other than myself, Doc and Carl. Nerboo 2 11 months ago
Guidelines? Spectral Convergence 13 12 months ago
Why Critique Groups Don't Work Nerboo 10 12 months ago
i love the concept. catklein 11 12 months ago

About No Fluff

Several years ago, a group surfaced in which you would submit a photo to the group to the group and you would get a critique. It died a quick death in that it took up too much time of the group owners in that they were too busy taking photos of their own to provide the type of feedback that was required.

But now it's back. The guidelines are simple. You post a photo to the group and you must critique the photo immediately next to it int he group pool. And by critique I don't mean a fawn over, let me jack you off type of critique. Be harsh, be critical. Be a bitch. Or bastard. Words that comfort don't make good photographers.

Additional Information

This group is public This is a public group.

  • Accepted media types:
    • Photos
    • Video
  • Accepted content types:
    • Photos / Videos
    • Screenshots / Screencasts
    • Illustration/Art / Animation/CGI
  • Accepted safety levels:
    • Safe
RSS 2.0 feed Subscribe to a feed of stuff on this page... Feed – Subscribe to No Fluff discussion threads