Fake Takara Blythe Galore / Discuss

Current Discussion

Do you need help identifying your Blythe?
Latest: 3 months ago
dont forget the trademarks - head and body
Latest: 5 months ago
Blythe purchase #1 for me...
Latest: 5 months ago
My Thoughts On The Whole Fake Controversy
Latest: 6 months ago
Alibaba.com
Latest: 11 months ago
Statement from Hasbro
Latest: 13 months ago
anyone want to load their 'fake' UC off on me?
Latest: 13 months ago
Is my Nicky Lad fake?
Latest: 14 months ago
Fakes or Defects?
Latest: 14 months ago
List your fake Blythes and sellers here.
Latest: 15 months ago
Noooooooooo!! I think I got a fake urban cow girl!!
Latest: 15 months ago
Great news!! I can prove my UC is not RBL mold!!!!!!!!
Latest: 15 months ago
More...

Search this group's discussions

My Thoughts On The Whole Fake Controversy

view profile

blythesnob  Pro User  says:

i'm not an expert, nor do i own a fake- but i've been doing a lot of research on the topic and read a ton of junko's blog posts about the factory girls and fakes and here's my theory on what's probably going on:

it could be that when takara commissions a factory to make the dolls for them, takara has them use high quality materials and the factory is under contact to ONLY made the dolls for takara, who then ships the dolls out to their merchants. IF the factory chose to make dolls on the side and sell them to ebay people and other sellers- they decided to cut corners and use cheap materials and plastics with NO quality control. think about it- they have the machines right there! they have the molds. they can produce dolls on the side when takara isn't looking. it would explain why these fakes are soooo close to the originals. because they are being made in the same factories. the only difference is- they are NOT using the good materials that takara requires- they are using cheap materials to get the job done. they might even be using the same boxes and clothes- the only difference is the plastics and hairs. it just doesn't make sense to me. something is so wrong. and another thing: i've heard junko talk about using multiple factories over the years to make blythes. what if one of the older facorites who used to work for takara is doing this behind takara's back because takara moved their business to a new factory? they still might have all the molds, etc. to be able to make a full doll- albeit a crappy quality copy- but still- from the outside- she looks so similar. we, the collectors, are the only ones who can tell them apart.

i hate to say it guys, but the only way we can be 100% sure of buying a REAL bltyhe is to go through junie moon or other "official" shops and sellers. SUCKS- cause we're gonna pay more- but it is what it is... for now anyway. i don't see how takara can stop this. look at the factory girls- those are just made up of left-over parts. and junko said it makes her sick but she can't stop it.

it's all very, very sad...
Posted at 6:44AM, 18 February 2011 PDT (permalink)

view photostream

tinycutethings  Pro User  says:

It's such a sad situation for Blythe lovers. I came into the hobby recently and the only way to get older NRFB releases at lower prices is through the secondary market.
Posted 15 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Julianahom says:

This can a be a explanation for what is happening. But I got to adimit as I got a Urban Cow Girl that may be a fake that the quality of the materials are good, the problem is that they don't give a damm to quality control and we have no one to go to solve our problems. Takara should do something like use a holografic stamp or whatever so we can be more sure we are buying a original doll because it's almost impossible to buy Blythe from the official shops from Brazil, for exemple.
Originally posted 15 months ago. (permalink)
Julianahom edited this topic 15 months ago.

view photostream

blythesnob  Pro User  says:

yes it is! i feel the same way and i'm super worried about buying blythes in the future!

awesome idea! they have to do something! some way to let us know they are authentic blythes. but i bet it's a tough task to accomplish when the copiers will just copy that as well. it's really upsetting me...
Posted 15 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

G♥Baby  Pro User  says:

I just dont understand why it's so hard to find the people responsible for making these fakes. Especially considering the fact that we know who is selling them, all they have to do is trace back to where that ebay seller bought their dolls from and keep tracing back from there.. It's not like there's hundreds of different factories making them.
Posted 15 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

iBlythe says:

Totally agree and have thought the same thing. Unless it starts hurting sales of the real dolls though (and not just the secondary market) I don't know that they care. It could even work to their advantage.
Posted 15 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

noituudenaika  Pro User  says:

Counterfeit operations are very prevalent in China so the police are probably too busy tracking down manufacturers of fake medications (that have been discovered in pharmacies all around the world) instead of fake dolls unfortunately :( I believe they have very harsh penalties for this kind of behaviour though so maybe they will get caught some day.
Posted 15 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

pariszhenpink  Pro User  says:

Totally agree with Blythesnob's theory. My fakes look like all substandard materials....and i think the face mold might have been one that was considered "retired" lol....because the facial expression isn't right. But no matter, i will try to do something with them...customize them because its so sad to think of throwing them in the trash?!
Posted 13 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

MinkiDynamite is a group administrator MinkiDynamite  Pro User  says:

I bet your custom girls will be as lovely as "real" Takara customs. I don't see any reason to trash them, it's not like it's the dolls fault of being fake. ;)
Posted 13 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

Helena / Funny Bunny  Pro User  says:

I joined this group, I wanted to share this link:
money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2006/05/0...

quoting:
"In addition to literal night-shift activity, the "third shift" is an umbrella term for any form of unauthorized production by otherwise authorized contractors. A common variant arises when a brand owner tells an overseas contractor to stop producing a line of product, and the contractor doesn't.

"You've taught a company to produce something," says one China-based investigator who requested anonymity, "and perhaps that's all those people know how to do. Just because you have agreements doesn't mean those people are going to stop doing what they've learned."

It looks plausible.. I have read somewhere (do not remember where, sorry) that CWC have used some different factories.. so maybe one factory got the message that they are to stop producing.. maybe they went on producing..

And the thought on SBL-looking mold but with RBL construction. Maybe when they made RBL they also made SBL to have the new construction and have made some prototypes but eventually got discarded and the factory used the prototype to make these clones?

Of course just guessing on my part.
I have got no clones in my collection but I am just damn curious about this whole thing.

I have been on Blythes since 2004 and I have memories of TIB discussions back in early times about people buying dolls from china and that these were a little more bad in QC... I am talking about the EBL/early SBL era... I wonder if this night shift thing or lets' say factory blythe thing is actually older than we think?
Posted 12 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

MinkiDynamite is a group administrator MinkiDynamite  Pro User  says:

Thanks a lot for sharing, that sounds very plausible!
Posted 12 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

noituudenaika  Pro User  says:

I noticed some sellers claiming to sell Blythe dolls on Alibaba.com that clearly are not.

www.alibaba.com/product-gs/358111426/blythe_doll.html
Posted 12 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

noituudenaika  Pro User  says:

Other sellers with "Blythes"
www.alibaba.com/product-gs/293211636/blythe_doll.html
www.alibaba.com/product-gs/358123198/blythe_toy_plastic.html
Posted 12 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

AℓℓieCat says:

I bet the 2nd link isn't even the actual doll they're selling. Looks like they stole a picture from an original blythe kenner =O
Posted 12 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

noituudenaika  Pro User  says:

Yeah I thought that too, I would like to see what one of their dolls looks like that seller has about 20 different ones. I hope they are real as it would be scary if that many had been faked.
Posted 12 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

MinkiDynamite is a group administrator MinkiDynamite  Pro User  says:

I think the fake ones here are not faked Blythes in regard 1:1 copies of releases, as far as I can see the first is a doll that has been produced by a fashion company a few years ago. I could be mistaken though.

But it's a shame that those are sold as real Blythes.
Posted 12 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

smittenwithblythe  Pro User  says:

This one doesn't even look like a Blythe! How bizarre!


I noticed some sellers claiming to sell Blythe dolls on Alibaba.com that clearly are not.

www.alibaba.com/product-gs/358111426/blythe_doll.html
Posted 8 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

noituudenaika  Pro User  says:

I have found a person that is trying to sell me these dodgy nude fakes, I asked her if she had any that looked like Mango and she said ohhh and sent me pics of a Mango and Guava in boxes. I am going to ask for closer pics of the scalp etc.

By pointing out that people are selling similar dolls, all I was trying to show was that they are making dolls like Blythe so some people could be making dolls exactly like Blythe as fakes.
Posted 6 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

noituudenaika  Pro User  says:

222am.blogspot.com/2011/11/blythe-scammers-part-6-ongoing...
Posted 6 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

MinkiDynamite is a group administrator MinkiDynamite  Pro User  says:

Thank you so much for your investigation! :D
I wonder if this Kary is always the same person, in my opinion the first email sounds like a different person from the latter. Not that it matters. ^^
Posted 6 months ago. (permalink)

view photostream

noituudenaika  Pro User  says:

I don't think it is the same person, they probably just use some pretty girls photo to sell the stuff I'd say. Her English certainly improved all of a sudden.
Posted 6 months ago. (permalink)

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

RSS 2.0 feedSubscribe to a feed of stuff on this page...</!!> Feed – Subscribe to Fake Takara Blythe Galore discussion threads